SECURITY NATIONAL FINANCIAL CORP – 10-K – Management’s Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations
Edgar Online, Inc. |
Overview
The Company's operations over the last several years generally reflect three trends or events which the Company expects to continue: (i) increased attention to "niche" insurance products, such as the Company's funeral plan policies and traditional whole life products; (ii) emphasis on cemetery and mortuary business; and (iii) capitalizing on low interest rates by originating and refinancing mortgage loans.
Insurance Operations
The Company's insurance business includes funeral plans, and interest sensitive life insurance as well as other traditional life and accident and health insurance products. The Company places specific marketing emphasis on funeral plans through pre-need planning. A funeral plan is a small face value life insurance policy that generally has face coverage of up to$25,000 . The Company believes that funeral plans represent a marketing niche that has lower competition because most insurance companies do not offer similar coverage. The purpose of the funeral plan policy is to pay the costs and expenses incurred at the time of the person's death. On a per thousand dollar cost of insurance basis these policies can be more expensive to the policy holder than many types of non-burial insurance due to their low face amount, requiring the fixed cost of the policy administration be distributed over a smaller policy size, and the simplified underwriting practices that result in higher mortality costs.
The following table shows the financial results for the Company's insurance operations for the years ended
16 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Years ended December 31 (in thousands of dollars) 2012 vs 2011 2011 vs 2010 % Increase % Increase 2012 2011 (Decrease) 2010 (Decrease) Revenues from external customers Insurance premiums $ 48,216 $ 48,457 0 % $ 38,509 26 % Net investment income 17,951 17,296 4 % 14,738 17 % Other 690 1,468 (53 %) 2,008 (27 %) Total $ 66,857 $ 67,221 (1 %) $ 55,255 22 % Intersegment revenue $ 7,571 $ 5,833 30 % $ 6,817 (14 %) Earnings before income taxes $ 4,591 $ 2,698 70 % $ 1,860 45 % Intersegment revenues for the Company's insurance operations are primarily interest income from the warehouse line provided toSecurityNational Mortgage Company . Profitability in 2012 has improved due to increases in net investment income, increases in intersegment revenues and decreases in expenses.
Life Insurance Acquisitions, Mergers and Reinsurance
Reinsurance with
OnDecember 19, 2012 , the Company, through its wholly owned subsidiary, Security National Life, entered into a Coinsurance Agreement withMothe Life Insurance Company , aLouisiana domiciled insurance company, and a subsidiary,DLE Life Insurance Company , also aLouisiana domiciled life insurance company (collectively referred to as "Mothe Life"). The effective date of the Coinsurance Agreement wasNovember 1, 2012 . Under the terms of the Coinsurance Agreement, Security National Life agreed to reinsure certain insurance policies of Mothe Life in exchange for the settlement amount of$34,485,000 . In addition, the Coinsurance Agreement provided that effectiveNovember 1, 2012 , Mothe Life ceded and transferred to Security National Life, and Security National Life accepted and coinsured all of Mothe Life's contractual liabilities under the coinsured policies by means of indemnity reinsurance. OnDecember 18, 2012 , theLouisiana Department of Insurance approved the Coinsurance Agreement. The Coinsurance Agreement further provided that on and after the effective date ofNovember 1, 2012 , Security National Life was entitled to exercise all contractual rights of Mothe Life under the coinsured policies in accordance with the terms and provisions of such policies. Moreover, after the closing date ofDecember 19, 2012 , the Company agreed to be responsible for all the contractual liabilities under the coinsured policies, including the administration of the coinsured policies at its sole expense in accordance with the terms and conditions of a Service Agreement between Security National Life and Mothe Life. Pursuant to the terms of the Coinsurance Agreement, Security National Life paid a ceding commission to Mothe Life in the amount of$4,684,000 . As a result of the ceding commission, Mothe Life transferred$34,485,000 in assets and$39,169,000 in statutory reserves, or liabilities, to Security National Life.
Reinsurance with
OnMarch 30, 2011 , the Company, through its wholly owned subsidiary, Security National Life, completed a Coinsurance Agreement withNorth America Life Insurance Company ("North America Life"), aTexas domiciled insurance company. Under the terms of the Coinsurance Agreement, Security National Life agreed to reinsure certain insurance policies of North America Life in exchange for the settlement amount of$15,703,000 . Effective as ofDecember 1, 2010 , North America Life ceded or transferred to Security National Life, and Security National Life accepted and coinsured all of North America Life's contractual liabilities under the coinsured policies by means of indemnity reinsurance. The Coinsurance Agreement was approved by theTexas Department of Insurance . The Coinsurance Agreement also provides that on and after the effective date ofDecember 1, 2010 , Security National Life is entitled to exercise all contractual rights of North America Life under the coinsured policies in accordance with the terms and provisions of such policies. Moreover, after the closing date ofMarch 30, 2011 , the Company agreed to be responsible for all the contractual liabilities under the coinsured policies, including the administration of the coinsured policies at its sole expense in accordance with the terms and conditions of a services agreement. Pursuant to the terms of the Coinsurance Agreement, Security National Life paid a ceding commission to North America Life in the amount of$3,526,000 . In addition, North America Life transferred$15,703,000 in assets and$19,230,000 in statutory reserves, or liabilities net of due and deferred premiums, to Security National Life. The$15,703,000 in assets included$12,990,000 in cash,$9,000 in policy loans, and$2,704,000 in promissory notes secured by real estate properties located inBexar ,Liberty ,Travis andWilson Counties in theState of Texas . The promissory notes are also guaranteed by business entities and an individual. 17
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OnSeptember 1, 2011 , Security National Life, with the approval of theTexas Department of Insurance , assumed all of the policies that were issued by North America Life and previously assumed and coinsured pursuant to the terms of the Coinsurance Agreement. Security National Life has assumed the same terms and conditions as set forth in each policy and certificates of assumptions were sent to all policyholders. OnAugust 31, 2011 , the Company entered into a Stock Purchase Agreement with North America Life to purchase all of the outstanding shares of common stock ofTrans-Western Life Insurance Company ("Trans-Western"), aTexas domiciled insurance company and a wholly-owned subsidiary of North America Life. The Company completed the Stock Purchase Agreement onMay 2, 2012 . The purchase consideration paid was$494,000 , which was equal to the capital and surplus of Trans-Western onMay 2, 2012 . OnMarch 20, 2012 , theTexas Insurance Department approved the Stock Purchase Agreement, and all of Trans-Western's insurance business was ceded to North America Life, of which approximately 47% of the insurance in force was assumed by the Company under the Coinsurance Agreement as described in Note 9 of the Notes to Consolidated Statements. As part of the stock purchase transaction, the Company recaptured the 47% of insurance in force.
Cemetery and Mortuary Operations
The Company sells mortuary services and products through its seven mortuaries inSalt Lake City, Utah and one mortuary inPhoenix, Arizona . The Company also sells cemetery products and services through its five cemeteries inSalt Lake City, Utah and one cemetery inSan Diego County, California . Cemetery land sales and at-need product sales and services are recognized as revenue at the time of sale or when the services are performed. Pre-need cemetery product sales are deferred until the merchandise is delivered and services performed. OnMay 10, 2011 , the Company and its subsidiary,Greer-Wilson Funeral Home, Inc. , completed an asset sales transaction withSCI Arizona Funeral Services, Inc. ("SCI"), anArizona corporation, to sell substantially all of the operating assets ofGreer-Wilson Funeral Home andCrystal Rose Funeral Home to SCI. Under the terms of the asset purchase agreement amongGreer-Wilson Funeral Home ,Crystal Rose Funeral Home and SCI, SCI paid$2,225,000 at closing to the Company and Greer-Wilson . The agreement also granted a three year right of first refusal to SCI to purchaseParadise Chapel Funeral Home . If the Company elects to sellParadise Chapel Funeral Home within the three year period, the Company must provide a bona fide third party offer to SCI after which SCI has ten business days to exercise its right to purchase Paradise for the offer amount.
The following table shows the condensed financial results for the Company's cemetery and mortuary operations for the years ended
Years ended December 31 (in thousands of dollars) 2012 vs 2011 2011 vs 2010 % % Increase Increase 2012 2011 (Decrease) 2010 (Decrease) Revenues from external customers Mortuary revenues $ 4,567 $ 4,864 (6 %) $ 6,211 (22 %) Cemetery revenues 6,297 5,897 7 % 5,309 11 % Realized gains (losses) 9 868 (99 %) (27 ) (3315 %) Other 470 308 53 % 321 (4 %) Total $ 11,343 $ 11,937 (5 %) $ 11,814 1 % Earnings (Losses) before income taxes $ 219 $ 461 (52 %) $ (986 ) (147 %) The realized gain in the Company's cemetery and mortuary operations in 2011 was due to the sale ofGreer-Wilson Funeral Home andCrystal Rose Funeral Home . Included in other revenue was rental income from residential and commercial properties purchased from Security National Life.Memorial Estates purchased these properties from financing provided by Security National Life. The rental income was offset by property insurance, taxes, maintenance expenses and interest payments made to Security National Life.Memorial Estates recorded depreciation on these properties of$1,029,000 and$1,025,000 for the twelve months endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011, respectively. 18 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Mortgage Operations
Approximately 67% of the Company's revenues and expenses for the fiscal year 2012 were through its wholly owned subsidiary,SecurityNational Mortgage Company ("SecurityNational Mortgage").SecurityNational Mortgage is a mortgage lender incorporated under the laws of theState of Utah .SecurityNational Mortgage is approved and regulated by theFederal Housing Administration (FHA), a department of theU.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), to originate mortgage loans that qualify for government insurance in the event of default by the borrower.SecurityNational Mortgage obtains loans primarily from its retail offices and independent brokers.SecurityNational Mortgage funds the loans from internal cash flows, including loan purchase agreements fromSecurity National Life Insurance Company ("Security National Life"), and with unaffiliated financial institutions.SecurityNational Mortgage receives fees from the borrowers and other secondary fees from third party investors that purchase its loans.SecurityNational Mortgage sells its loans to third party investors and retains servicing on some of these loans.SecurityNational Mortgage pays the brokers and retail loan officers a commission for loans that are brokered throughSecurityNational Mortgage . For the twelve months endedDecember 31, 2012 , 2011 and 2010,SecurityNational Mortgage originated and sold 13,392 loans ($2,451,843,000 total volume), 8,100 loans ($1,407,212,000 total volume), and 11,251 loans ($2,094,738,000 total volume), respectively.SecurityNational Mortgage originates mortgage loans funded by the warehouse banks and immediately sells them to third party investors. Generally, when mortgage loans are sold to the warehouse banks,SecurityNational Mortgage is no longer obligated to pay the amounts outstanding on the mortgage loans, but is required to pay a fee in the form of interest on a portion of the mortgage loans between the date the loans are sold to warehouse banks and the settlement date with the third party investors. The terms of the loan purchase agreements are typically for one year, with interest accruing on a portion of the mortgage loans at annual rates ranging from 2.5% to 2.75% over the 30-day LIBOR rate. The mortgage loan volume in 2012 was higher than in 2011 primarily due to an increase in market share. The increase in market share was attributed to an expansion of the retail loan operations ofSecurityNational Mortgage .SecurityNational Mortgage anticipates the loan volume for 2013 to be approximately$125,000,000 to $240,000,000 per month range which was comparable to the per month range in 2012.SecurityNational Mortgage has entered into loan purchase agreements to originate and sell mortgage loans to two unaffiliated warehouse banks. OnMarch 19, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage andWells Fargo Bank, N.A. ("Wells Fargo") entered into a loan purchase agreement in which Wells Fargo agreed to provide a warehouse line of up to$55,000,000 to fund certain approved mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage . OnAugust 6, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage and Wells Fargo agreed to an amendment to theMarch 19, 2012 loan purchase agreement to increase the amount of the warehouse line available to fund mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage from$55,000,000 to$75,000,000 . OnJuly 16, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage andUBS Real Estate Securities Inc. ("UBS") entered into a loan purchase agreement in which UBS agreed to provide a warehouse line of up to$30,000,000 to fund mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage . OnOctober 26, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage and UBS agreed to an amendment to theJuly 16, 2012 loan purchase agreement to increase the amount of the warehouse line available to fund mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage from$30,000,000 to$40,000,000 .
The following table shows the condensed financial results for the Company's mortgage operations for the years 2012, 2011 and 2010. See Note 14 of the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.
Years ended December 31 (in thousands of dollars) 2012 vs 2011 2011 vs 2010 % Increase % Increase 2012 2011 (Decrease) 2010 (Decrease) Revenues from external customers Revenues from loan originations $ 120,749 $ 64,415 87 % $ 78,450 (18 %) Secondary gains from investors 29,804 13,190 126 % 18,892 (30 %) Total $ 150,553 $ 77,605 94 % $ 97,342 (20 %) Earnings (Losses) before income taxes $ 16,542 $ (1,922 ) 961 % $ (1,964 ) (2 %) 19
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The increase in earnings for the Company's mortgage operations for the twelve months ended
Mortgage Accounting Policy
Mortgage fee income consists of origination fees, processing fees and certain other income related to the origination and sale of mortgage loans. For mortgage loans sold to third party investors, mortgage fee income and related expenses are recognized pursuant to generally accepted accounting principles at the time the sales of the mortgage loans comply with the sales criteria for the transfer of financial assets. The sales criteria is as follows: (i) the transferred assets have been isolated fromSecurityNational Mortgage and its creditors, (ii) the transferee has the right to pledge or exchange the mortgage, and (iii)SecurityNational Mortgage does not maintain effective control over the transferred mortgage.SecurityNational Mortgage must determine that all three sales criteria are met at the time a mortgage loan is funded. All rights and title to the mortgage loans are assigned to unrelated financial institution investors, including investor commitments for the loans made prior to warehouse banks purchasing the loans under the purchase commitments. As ofDecember 31, 2012 , there was$201,681,000 in mortgage loans in which settlements with third party investors were still pending.
· Failure to deliver original documents specified by the investor. · The existence of misrepresentation or fraud in the origination of the loan.
· The loan becomes delinquent due to nonpayment during the first several
months after it is sold. · Early pay-off of a loan, as defined by the agreements. · Excessive time to settle a loan. · Investor declines purchase. · Discontinued product and expired commitment. Loan purchase commitments generally specify a date 30 to 45 days after delivery upon which the underlying loans should be settled. Depending on market conditions, these commitment settlement dates can be extended at a cost toSecurityNational Mortgage . Generally, a ten day extension will cost .125% (12.5 basis points) of the loan amount.SecurityNational Mortgage's historical data shows that 99% of all loans originated are generally settled by the investors as agreed within 20 days after delivery. There are situations, however, whenSecurityNational Mortgage determines that it is unable to enforce the settlement of loans rejected by the third-party investors and that it is in its best interest to repurchase those loans from the warehouse banks. It isSecurityNational Mortgage's policy to cure any documentation problems regarding such loans at a minimal cost for up to a six-month time period and to pursue efforts to enforce loan purchase commitments from third-party investors concerning the loans.SecurityNational Mortgage believes that six months allows adequate time to remedy any documentation issues, to enforce purchase commitments, and to exhaust other alternatives. Remedial methods include the following: · Research reasons for rejection. · Provide additional documents. · Request investor exceptions. · Appeal rejection decision to purchase committee. · Commit to secondary investors. Once purchase commitments have expired and other alternatives to remedy are exhausted, which could be earlier than the six month time period, the loans are repurchased and transferred to the long term investment portfolio at the lower of cost or market value and previously recorded sales revenue is reversed. Any loan that later becomes delinquent is evaluated bySecurityNational Mortgage at that time and any impairment is adjusted accordingly. Determining lower of cost or market. Cost is equal to the amount paid to the warehouse bank and the amount originally funded bySecurityNational Mortgage . Market value, while often difficult to determine, is based on the following guidelines: 20 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
· For loans that have an active market,
market price on the repurchase date.
· For loans where there is no market but there is a similar product,
on the repurchase date.
· For loans where no active market exists on the repurchase date,
best approximates the market value on the repurchase date, after
considering the fair value of the underlying real estate collateral and
estimated future cash flows.
The appraised value of the real estate underlying the original mortgage loan adds significance toSecurityNational Mortgage's determination of fair value because, if the loan becomes delinquent,SecurityNational Mortgage has sufficient value to collect the unpaid principal balance or the carrying value of the loan. In determining the market value on the date of repurchase,SecurityNational Mortgage considers the total value of all of the loans because any sale of loans would be made as a pool.
For mortgages originated and held for investment, mortgage fee income and related expenses are recognized when the loan is originated.
As ofDecember 31, 2012 , the Company's long term mortgage loan portfolio consisted of$11,679,000 in mortgage loans with delinquencies more than 90 days. Of this amount,$6,039,000 of the loans were in foreclosure proceedings. The Company has not received or recognized any interest income on the$11,679,000 in mortgage loans with delinquencies more than 90 days. During the twelve months endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011, the Company increased its allowance for mortgage losses by$434,000 and$1,236,000 , respectively, which was charged to loan loss expense and included in selling, general and administrative expenses for the period. The allowances for mortgage loan losses as ofDecember 31, 2012 and 2011 were$4,240,000 and$4,881,000 , respectively. Also atDecember 31, 2012 , the Company had foreclosed on a total of$60,710,000 in long term mortgage loans, of which$17,020,000 of the loans foreclosed were reclassified as other real estate held for investment or sale during 2012. The Company carries the foreclosed properties in Security National Life,Memorial Estates , andSecurityNational Mortgage , its respective life, cemeteries and mortuaries, and mortgage subsidiaries, and will rent the properties until it is deemed economically desirable to sell them.
Mortgage Loan Loss Settlements
The mortgage industry has seen potential loan losses increase. Future loan losses are extremely difficult to estimate, especially in the current market. However, management believes that the Company's reserve methodology and its current practice of property preservation allow it to estimate its losses on loans sold. The amounts accrued for loan losses in years endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011 were$4,053,000 and$1,668,000 , respectively. The estimated liability for indemnification losses is included in other liabilities and accrued expenses and, as ofDecember 31, 2012 and 2011, the balances were$6,035,000 and$2,338,000 , respectively.
Settlement with Wells Fargo
OnApril 7, 2011 ,SecurityNational Mortgage entered into a settlement agreement withWells Fargo Funding, Inc. ("Wells Fargo"). The settlement agreement provides that it is intended to be a pragmatic commercial accommodation betweenSecurityNational Mortgage and Wells Fargo and is not to be construed as an admission of responsibility, liability or fault for either party's claims. Under the terms of the settlement agreement,SecurityNational Mortgage paid an initial settlement amount to Wells Fargo in the amount of$4,300,000 , of which$1,000,000 had already been paid to Wells Fargo inJanuary 2011 , leaving a balance of$3,300,000 . The$3,300,000 balance was paid shortly after the parties executed the settlement agreement. In addition, under the terms of the settlement agreement, Wells Fargo has the right to deduct 10 basis points (.0010) from the purchase proceeds of each loan thatSecurityNational Mortgage sells to Wells Fargo during the period fromApril 8, 2011 toMarch 31, 2017 . The amounts deducted by Wells Fargo for years endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011 were$2,674,269 and$928,075 , respectively, representing 10 basis points from the purchase proceeds of the loans thatSecurityNational Mortgage sold to Wells Fargo during that period.SecurityNational Mortgage is also required under the settlement agreement to set aside 10 basis points (.0010) during the period fromApril 8, 2011 toMarch 31, 2017 from the purchase proceeds of any loans that it sells to any mortgage loan purchaser other than Wells Fargo and pay such amounts to Wells Fargo. The amounts deducted by Wells Fargo for the years endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011 were$617,740 and$80,554 , respectively, representing 10 basis points from the purchase proceeds of the loans it sold to mortgage loan purchasers other than Wells Fargo during that period. 21 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Finally,SecurityNational Mortgage is required under the settlement agreement to set aside 50% from the net proceeds that it receives from any sale, liquidation or other transfer of certain real estate properties that it owns, after subtracting taxes, commissions, recording fees and other transaction costs. These real estate properties consist of 27 real estate properties with a total book value of$5,404,900 as ofDecember 31, 2012 . Thus far, none of these real estate properties have been sold, liquidated or transferred. In consideration forSecurityNational Mortgage making the initial settlement payment to Wells Fargo, Wells Fargo and related parties, includingWells Fargo Bank , releasedSecurityNational Mortgage and related parties, including the Company and Security National Life, from any claims, demands, damages, obligations, liabilities, or causes of action relating to residential mortgage loans that Wells Fargo purchased fromSecurityNational Mortgage prior toDecember 31, 2009 . Similarly,SecurityNational Mortgage released Wells Fargo and its related parties from any claims, demands, damages, obligations, liabilities, or causes of actions relating to residential mortgage loans that Wells Fargo purchased fromSecurityNational Mortgage prior toDecember 31, 2009 .
Mortgage Loan Loss Demands
There have been assertions in third party investor correspondence thatSecurityNational Mortgage sold mortgage loans that allegedly contained misrepresentations or experienced early payment defaults, or that were otherwise allegedly defective or not in compliance with agreements betweenSecurityNational Mortgage and the third party investors consisting principally of financial institutions. As a result of these claims, third party investors have made demands thatSecurityNational Mortgage repurchase certain alleged defective mortgage loans that were sold to such investors or indemnify them against any losses related to such loans. As ofDecember 31, 2012 , third party investors had asserted total potential claims and notices of potential claims relating to mortgage loan repurchases, indemnifications and other issues that are substantially greater than$25,000,000 . Additional potential claims and notices of potential claims from third party investors have been made sinceDecember 31, 2012 . The Company has reserved and accrued$6,035,000 as ofDecember 31, 2012 to settle all such investor related claims. The total amount of potential claims and notices of potential claims are greater than the net asset value ofSecurityNational Mortgage , which was$26,835,000 onDecember 31, 2012 , and its reserve for mortgage loan loss, which was$6,035,000 onDecember 31, 2012 .SecurityNational Mortgage disagrees with the claims and notices of potential claims asserted by third party investors against it and believes it has significant defenses to these claims. Any additional losses in excess of the current loan loss reserve cannot be estimated asSecurityNational Mortgage is currently in the process of reviewing repurchase demands and notices of potential claims from third party investors. IfSecurityNational Mortgage is unable to resolve demands by the third party investors on acceptable terms, legal action may ensue in an effort to obtain amounts that the third party investors claim are allegedly due. In the event of legal action, ifSecurityNational Mortgage is not successful in its defenses against claims asserted by these third party investors to the extent that a substantial judgment is entered againstSecurityNational Mortgage which is beyond its capacity to pay,SecurityNational Mortgage may be required to curtail or cease operations. JP Morgan Chase Indemnification Demand The Company and its wholly-owned subsidiary,SecurityNational Mortgage , received a notice of claim for indemnification datedDecember 21, 2011 , relating to mortgage loans thatEMC Mortgage, LLC ("EMC Mortgage") allegedly purchased as a third party investor fromSecurityNational Mortgage . The notice was from JP Morgan Chase & Co. ("JP Morgan Chase") on behalf ofEMC Mortgage . According to the notice, the alleged indemnification claim relates to mortgage loans thatSecurityNational Mortgage sold toEMC Mortgage under a Mortgage Loan Purchase Agreement, datedDecember 5, 2005 , betweenSecurityNational Mortgage and EMC. The notice also referenced an Agreement of Guaranty, datedFebruary 23, 2006 , by the Company relative toEMC Mortgage . The notice states thatEMC Mortgage allegedly purchased mortgage loans fromSecurityNational Mortgage , which were later securitized by means of mortgage pass-through certificates. The notice of indemnification claim from JP Morgan Chase also states thatEMC Mortgage has been named in a lawsuit by theBear Stearns Mortgage Funding Trust 2007-AR2 (the "Trust"), which was filed onSeptember 13, 2011 in theDelaware Court of Chancery . A copy of the complaint and the amended complaint was provided to the Company by JP Morgan Chase. The amended complaint contends that more than 800 residential mortgage loans thatEMC Mortgage sold to the Trust contained breaches of representations and warranties concerning the mortgage loans. The amended complaint also contends that despiteEMC Mortgage's assurance to the Trust that the mortgage loans met certain minimum quality standards, there have been defaults and foreclosures in many of such loans. As a result of the alleged defaults and foreclosures, the amended complaint asserts thatEMC Mortgage is required to repurchase from the Trust any loans in which it breached its representations and warranties, in the amount of the mortgage loans' outstanding principal balance and all accrued but unpaid interest. 22 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The notice from JP Morgan Chase further states that the Company andSecurityNational Mortgage are required to indemnifyEMC Mortgage for any losses arising from the lawsuit against EMC based upon alleged untrue statements of material fact related to information that was provided bySecurityNational Mortgage . The amended complaint includes the loan numbers of the alleged non-complying mortgage loans thatEMC Mortgage sold to the Trust. In a letter datedFebruary 7, 2012 , from JP Morgan Chase that accompanied a copy of the amended complaint, JP Morgan Chase asserted that 21 mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage were included in the lawsuit as part of the alleged non-complying mortgage loans that EMC allegedly sold to the Trust. Thus, it appears that only a very small percentage of the alleged non-complying mortgage loans thatEMC Mortgage sold to the Trust were mortgage loans thatSecurityNational Mortgage had sold to EMC. Moreover, to the extent the claims by the Trust againstEMC Mortgage relate to mortgage loans thatSecurityNational Mortgage sold to EMC, the Company believes it has defenses to such claims with respect to EMC. For example, neither the Company norSecurityNational Mortgage is a party to any agreement involving the Trust, nor are they privy to any agreements betweenEMC Mortgage and the Trust. The Company intends to vigorously defend itself andSecurityNational Mortgage in the event that JP Morgan Chase were to bring any legal action to require the Company orSecurityNational Mortgage to indemnify it for any loss, liability or expense in connection with the lawsuit that the Trust has brought againstEMC Mortgage .
Mortgage Loan Loss Litigation
Lehman Brothers - Aurora Loan Services Litigation
OnApril 15, 2005 ,SecurityNational Mortgage entered into a loan purchase agreement withLehman Brothers Bank , FSB ("Lehman Bank "). Under the terms of the loan purchase agreement,Lehman Bank agreed to purchase mortgage loans from time to time fromSecurityNational Mortgage . During 2007,Lehman Bank and its wholly owned subsidiary,Aurora Loan Services LLC ("Aurora Loan Services"), purchased a total of 1,490 mortgage loans in the aggregate amount of$352,774,000 fromSecurityNational Mortgage .Lehman Bank asserted that certain of the mortgage loans that it purchased fromSecurityNational Mortgage during 2007 contained alleged misrepresentations and early payment defaults. As a result of these alleged breaches in the mortgage loans,Lehman Bank contended it had the right to requireSecurityNational Mortgage SecurityNational Mortgage disagrees with these claims. OnDecember 17, 2007 ,SecurityNational Mortgage entered into an Indemnification Agreement withLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services . Under the terms of the Indemnification Agreement,SecurityNational Mortgage agreed to indemnifyLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services for 75% of all losses thatLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services may incur relative to breaches by mortgagors pertaining to 54 mortgage loans that were purchased fromSecurityNational Mortgage .SecurityNational Mortgage was released from any obligation to pay the remaining 25% of such losses. The Indemnification Agreement also requiredSecurityNational Mortgage to indemnifyLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services for 100% of any future losses incurred on mortgage loans with breaches that were not among the 54 mortgage loans. Pursuant to the Indemnification Agreement,SecurityNational Mortgage paid$395,000 toAurora Loan Services as a deposit into a reserve account, to secure any obligations ofSecurityNational Mortgage under the Indemnification Agreement. This deposit was in addition to a$250,000 deposit thatSecurityNational Mortgage previously made into the reserve account for a total of$645,000 . Losses from mortgage loans with alleged breaches were payable from the reserve account. However,Lehman Bank andAurora Loan Services were not to apply any funds from the reserve account to a particular mortgage loan until an actual loss had occurred. Under the Indemnification Agreement SecurityNational Mortgage was to pay toAurora Loan Services each calendar month the difference between the reserve account balance and$645,000 , but in no event wouldSecurityNational Mortgage be required to make payments into the reserve account in excess of$125,000 for any calendar month. 23 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Since the reserve account was established, funds had been paid from the account to indemnify$4,281,000 in alleged losses from 31 mortgage loans that were among 54 mortgage loans with alleged breaches that were covered by the Indemnification Agreement and ten other mortgage loans with alleged breaches. In the last monthly billing statement datedApril 24, 2011 toSecurityNational Mortgage , Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. ("Lehman Holdings ") claimed thatSecurityNational Mortgage owed approximately$3,745,000 for mortgage loan losses under the Indemnification Agreement. During 2010 and 2011, the Company recognized alleged losses of$1,289,000 and$-0 -, respectively. However, management cannot fully determine the total losses because there may be potential claims for losses that have not yet been determined. As ofDecember 31, 2012 , the Company had not accrued for any losses under the Indemnification Agreement.SecurityNational Mortgage was involved in discussions withLehman Bank andLehman Holdings concerning issues under the Indemnification Agreement. During the discussion period, monthly payments forDecember 2010 and January, February, March and April of 2011 totaling$625,000 were abated or deferred. OnMay 11, 2011 ,SecurityNational Mortgage filed a complaint againstAurora Bank FSB , formerly known asLehman Bank , andAurora Loan Services in theUnited States District Court for the District of Utah because it had been unable to resolve certain issues under the Indemnification Agreement. The complaint alleges, among other things, material breach of the Indemnification Agreement, including a claim that neitherLehman Bank norAurora Loan Services owned mortgage loans sold by SecurityNational to justify the amount of payments demanded from, and made bySecurityNational Mortgage . As a result,SecurityNational Mortgage claims it is entitled to judgment of approximately$4,000,000 againstLehman Bank , as well asAurora Loan Services to the extent of its involvement and complicity withLehman Bank . The complaint also alleges a second claim for material breach of a section of the Indemnification Agreement that contains an alleged "sunset" provision and that the amount of the requested payments made was not justified under the "sunset" provision. OnJune 8, 2011 ,Lehman Holdings , which had filed for bankruptcy inSeptember 2008 , filed a complaint againstSecurityNational Mortgage in theUnited States District Court for the District of Utah . ALehman Holdings' subsidiary ownsLehman Bank . The complaint alleges thatSecurityNational Mortgage sold loans toLehman Bank , which were then sold toLehman Holdings . The complaint additionally alleges thatLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services assigned their rights and remedies under the loan purchase agreement, as well as the Indemnification Agreement toLehman Holdings , which latter assignment purportedly took place onMarch 28, 2011 .Lehman Holdings declared in a letter datedJune 2, 2011 that the Indemnification Agreement was null and void, which is disputed bySecurityNational Mortgage .Lehman Holdings' alleged claims are for damages for breach of contract and breach of warranty pursuant to a loan purchase agreement and Seller's Guide. Based on claiming that the Indemnification Agreement is null and void pursuant to its lawsuit,Lehman Holdings has initially claimed damages in excess of$5,000,000 . Prior to declaring the Indemnification Agreement null and void,Lehman Holdings claimed in a then recent billing statement under the terms of the Indemnification Agreement, thatSecurityNational Mortgage owed approximately$3,745,000 for mortgage loan losses under the Indemnification Agreement.SecurityNational Mortgage strongly disagrees with the position ofLehman Holdings and, as set forth in itsMay 11, 2011 complaint, seeks affirmative relief of approximately$4,000,000 fromLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services , which are related toLehman Holdings . OnSeptember 4, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage filed a motion for summary judgment in its action againstLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services on certain material issues, as well as againstLehman Holdings regarding its claims againstSecurityNational Mortgage .Lehman Bank andAurora Loan Services filed a cross motion for summary judgment as to the issues inSecurityNational Mortgage's motion and, in theLehman Holdings case,Lehman Holdings has requested that the Court allow a cross motion on the issues which are the subject ofSecurityNational Mortgage's September 4, 2012 motion. The cases are before two different federal judges. OnFebruary 27, 2013 ,SecurityNational Mortgage's motion for summary judgment againstLehman Bank andAurora Loan Services and the related cross motion were heard by JudgeDavid Nuffer of theUnited States District Court for the District of Utah . After an extensive hearing,Judge Nuffer requested that the parties prepare findings of fact in accordance with the Court's earlier promulgated findings as modified at the hearing, and that each party submit proposed conclusions of law related to the motions.Judge Nuffer also said that he may request a further hearing on the matter.SecurityNational Mortgage's motion in theLehman Holdings case is presently set for hearing onMay 30, 2013 before JudgeTed Stewart of theUnited States District Court for the District of Utah . 24 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Prearranged funeral and pre-need cemetery customer obtaining costs - costs incurred related to obtaining new pre-need cemetery and prearranged funeral business are accounted for under the guidance of the provisions of GAAP related to Financial Services - Insurance. Obtaining costs, which include only costs that vary with and are primarily related to the acquisition of new pre-need cemetery and prearranged funeral business, are deferred until the merchandise is delivered or services are performed. Revenues and costs for at-need sales are recorded when a valid contract exists, the services are performed, collection is reasonably assured and there are no significant obligations remaining.
Mortgage Operations
Mortgage fee income is generated through the origination and refinancing of mortgage loans and is realized in accordance with GAAP related to sales of financial assets.
The majority of loans originated are sold to third party investors. The amounts sold to investors are shown on the balance sheet as mortgage loans sold to investors, and include the fees due from the investors.
Use of Significant Accounting Estimates
The preparation of financial statements in conformity with GAAP requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect reported amounts and disclosures. It is reasonably possible that actual experience could differ from the estimates and assumptions utilized which could have a material impact on the financial statements. The following is a summary of our significant accounting estimates, and critical issues that impact them:
Fixed Maturities and Equity Securities Available for Sale
Securities available for sale are carried at estimated fair value, with unrealized holding gains and losses reported in accumulated other comprehensive income, which is included in stockholders' equity after adjustment for deferred income taxes and deferred acquisition costs related to universal life products.
When the value of a security declines and the decline is determined to be other than temporary, the carrying value of the investment is reduced to its fair value and a realized loss is recorded to the extent of the decline.
Deferred Acquisition Costs
Amortization of deferred policy acquisition costs for interest sensitive products is dependent upon estimates of current and future gross profits or margins on this business. Key assumptions used include the following: yield on investments supporting the liabilities, amount of interest or dividends credited to the policies, amount of policy fees and charges, amount of expenses necessary to maintain the policies, amount of death and surrender benefits, and the length of time the policies will stay in force. For nonparticipating traditional life products, these costs are amortized over the premium paying period of the related policies in proportion to the ratio of annual premium revenues to total anticipated premium revenues. Such anticipated premium revenues are estimated using the same assumption used for computing liabilities for future policy benefits and are generally "locked in" at the date the policies are issued. Value of Business Acquired Value of business acquired is the present value of estimated future profits of the acquired business and is amortized similar to deferred acquisition costs. The critical issues explained for deferred acquisition costs would also apply for value of business acquired.
Allowance for Doubtful Accounts
The Company accrues an estimate of potential losses for the collection of receivables. The significant receivables are the result of receivables due on mortgage loans sold to investors, cemetery and mortuary operations, mortgage loan operations and other receivables. The allowance is based upon the Company's experience. The critical issue that would impact recovery of the cemetery and mortuary receivables is the overall economy. The critical issues that would impact recovery of mortgage loan operations would be interest rate risk and loan underwriting. Future Policy Benefits Reserves for future policy benefits for traditional life insurance products requires the use of many assumptions, including the duration of the policies, mortality experience, expenses, investment yield, lapse rates, surrender rates, and dividend crediting rates. 25
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Significant Accounting Policies
The following is a brief summary of our significant accounting policies and a review of our most critical accounting estimates. See Note 1 of the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements.
Insurance Operations
In accordance with accounting principles generally accepted inthe United States of America (GAAP), premiums and considerations received for interest sensitive products such as universal life insurance and ordinary annuities are reflected as increases in liabilities for policyholder account balances and not as revenues. Revenues reported for these products consist of policy charges for the cost of insurance, administration charges, amortization of policy initiation fees and surrender charges assessed against policyholder account balances. Surrender benefits paid relating to these products are reflected as decreases in liabilities for policyholder account balances and not as expenses.
The Company receives investment income earned from the funds deposited into account balances, a portion of which is passed through to the policyholders in the form of interest credited. Interest credited to policyholder account balances and benefit claims in excess of policyholder account balances are reported as expenses in the consolidated financial statements.
Premium revenues reported for traditional life insurance products are recognized as revenues when due. Future policy benefits are recognized as expenses over the life of the policy by means of the provision for future policy benefits. The costs related to acquiring new business, including certain costs of issuing policies and other variable selling expenses (principally commissions), defined as deferred policy acquisition costs, are capitalized and amortized into expense. For nonparticipating traditional life products, these costs are amortized over the premium paying period of the related policies, in proportion to the ratio of annual premium revenues to total anticipated premium revenues. Such anticipated premium revenues are estimated using the same assumption used for computing liabilities for future policy benefits and are generally "locked in" at the date the policies are issued. For interest sensitive products, these costs are amortized generally in proportion to expected gross profits from surrender charges and investment, mortality and expense margins. This amortization is adjusted when the Company revises the estimate of current or future gross profits or margins. For example, deferred policy acquisition costs are amortized earlier than originally estimated when policy terminations are higher than originally estimated or when investments backing the related policyholder liabilities are sold at a gain prior to their anticipated maturity. Death and other policyholder benefits reflect exposure to mortality risk and fluctuate from year to year on the level of claims incurred under insurance retention limits. The profitability of the Company is primarily affected by fluctuations in mortality, other policyholder benefits, expense levels, interest spreads (i.e., the difference between interest earned on investments and interest credited to policyholders) and persistency. The Company has the ability to mitigate adverse experience through sound underwriting, asset/liability duration matching, sound actuarial practices, adjustments to credited interest rates, policyholder dividends and cost of insurance charges.
Cemetery and Mortuary Operations
Pre-need sales of funeral services and caskets, including revenue and costs associated with the sales of pre-need funeral services and caskets, are deferred until the services are performed or the caskets are delivered.
Pre-need sales of cemetery interment rights (cemetery burial property) - revenue and costs associated with the sales of pre-need cemetery interment rights are recognized in accordance with the retail land sales provisions of accounting principles generally accepted inthe United States (GAAP). Under GAAP, recognition of revenue and associated costs from constructed cemetery property must be deferred until a minimum percentage of the sales price has been collected. Revenues related to the pre-need sale of unconstructed cemetery property will be deferred until such property is constructed and meets the criteria of FASB Codification Topic 360-20, described above.
Pre-need sales of cemetery merchandise (primarily markers and vaults) - revenue and costs associated with the sales of pre-need cemetery merchandise are deferred until the merchandise is delivered.
Pre-need sales of cemetery services (primarily merchandise delivery and installation fees and burial opening and closing fees) - revenue and costs associated with the sales of pre-need cemetery services are deferred until the services are performed.
26 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- These assumptions are made based upon historical experience, industry standards and a best estimate of future results and, for traditional life products, include a provision for adverse deviation. For traditional life insurance, once established for a particular series of products, these assumptions are generally held constant. Unearned Revenue The universal life products the Company sells have significant policy initiation fees (front-end load) that are deferred and amortized into revenues over the estimated expected gross profits from surrender charges and investment, mortality and expense margins. The same issues that impact deferred acquisition costs would apply to unearned revenue.
The revenue and cost associated with the sales of pre-need cemetery merchandise and funeral services are deferred until the merchandise is delivered or the service is performed.
The Company, through its cemetery and mortuary operations, provides a guaranteed funeral arrangement wherein a prospective customer can receive future goods and services at guaranteed prices. To accomplish this, the Company, through its life insurance operations, sells to the customer an increasing benefit life insurance policy that is assigned to the mortuaries. If, at the time of need, the policyholder/potential mortuary customer utilizes one of the Company's facilities, the guaranteed funeral arrangement contract that has been assigned will provide the funeral goods and services at the contracted price. The increasing life insurance policy will cover the difference between the original contract prices and current prices. Risks may arise if the difference cannot be fully met by the life insurance policy.
Mortgage Servicing Rights
Mortgage Service Rights (MSR) arise from contractual agreements between the Company and third-party investors (or their agents) when mortgage loans are sold. Under these contracts, the Company is obligated to retain and provide loan servicing functions on the loans sold, in exchange for fees and other remuneration. The servicing functions typically performed include, among other responsibilities, collecting and remitting loan payments; responding to borrower inquiries; accounting for principal and interest, holding custodial (impound) funds for payment of property taxes and insurance premiums; counseling delinquent mortgagors; and supervising the acquisition of REO and property dispositions. The Company initially accounts for MSRs at fair value and subsequently accounts for them using the amortization method. MSR amortization is determined by amortizing the balance straight-line over an estimated nine year life. The Company periodically assesses MSRs accounted for using the amortization method for impairment.
Mortgage Allowance for Loan Loss and Loan Loss Reserve
The Company provides allowances for losses on its mortgage loans through an allowance for loan losses (a contra-asset account) and through the mortgage loan loss reserve (a liability account). The allowance for loan losses is an allowance for losses on the Company's mortgage loans held for investment. The allowance is comprised of two components. The first component is an allowance for collectively evaluated impairment that is based upon the Company's historical experience in collecting similar receivables. The second component is based upon individual evaluation of loans that are determined to be impaired. Upon determining impairment the Company establishes an individual impairment allowance based upon an assessment of the fair value of the underlying collateral. When a mortgage loan is past due more than 90 days, the Company, where appropriate, sets up an allowance to approximate the excess of the carrying value of the mortgage loan over the estimated fair value of the underlying real estate collateral. Once a loan is past due more than 90 days the Company does not accrue any interest income and proceeds to foreclose on the real estate. All expenses for foreclosure are expensed as incurred. Once foreclosed the carrying value will approximate its fair value and the amount will be classified as real estate owned. The Company carries the foreclosed property in Security National Life,Memorial Estates andSecurityNational Mortgage , its life, cemeteries and mortuaries and mortgage subsidiaries, and will rent the properties until it is deemed desirable to sell them. The Company is currently able to rent properties at a 2% to 6% gross return. The mortgage loan loss reserve is an estimate of probable losses at the balance sheet date that the Company will realize in the future on mortgage loans sold to third party investors. The Company may be required to reimburse third party investors for costs associated with early payoff of loans within the first six months of such loans and to repurchase loans where there is a default in any of the first four monthly payments to the investors or, in lieu of repurchase, to pay a negotiated fee to the investors. The Company's estimates are based upon historical loss experience and the best estimate of the probable loan loss liabilities. 27 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Upon completion of a transfer that satisfies the conditions to be accounted for as a sale, the Company initially measures at fair value liabilities incurred in a sale relating to any guarantee or recourse provisions. The Company accrues a monthly allowance for indemnification losses to investors based on total production. This estimate is based on the Company's historical experience. The amount accrued for and the charge to expense is included in selling, general and administrative expenses. The estimated liability for indemnification losses is included in other liabilities and accrued expenses. The Company believes the allowance for loan losses and the loan loss reserve represent probable loan losses incurred as of the balance sheet date.
Deferred Compensation
The Company has deferred compensation agreements with several of its current and past executive officers. The deferred compensation is payable upon retirement or death of these individuals either in annual installments (ten years) or lump sum settlement, if approved by the Board of Directors. The Company has accrued the present value of these benefits based upon their future retirement dates and other factors, on its consolidated financial statements.
Depreciation
Depreciation is calculated principally on the straight-line-method over the estimated useful lives of the assets, which range from 3 to 40 years. Leasehold improvements are amortized over the lesser of the useful life or remaining lease terms.Self-Insurance The Company is self-insured for certain casualty insurance, workers compensation and liability programs.Self-Insurance reserves are maintained relative to these programs. The level of exposure from catastrophic events is limited by the purchase of stop-loss and aggregate liability reinsurance coverage. When estimating the self-insurance liabilities and related reserves, management considers a number of factors, which include historical claims experience, demographic factors, severity factors and valuations provided independent third-party actuaries. Management reviews its assumptions with its independent third-party administrators and actuaries to evaluate whether the self-insurance reserves are adequate. If actual claims or adverse development of loss reserves occurs and exceed these estimates, additional reserves may be required. The estimation process contains uncertainty since management must use judgment to estimate the ultimate cost that will be incurred to settle reported claims and unreported claims for incidents incurred but not reported as of the balance sheet date.
Results of Consolidated Operations
2012 Compared to 2011
Total revenues increased by$74,693,000 , or 46.8%, to$234,260,000 for fiscal year 2012 from$159,567,000 for the fiscal year 2011. Contributing to this increase in total revenues was a$72,948,000 increase in mortgage fee income, a$3,239,000 increase in net investment income, a$103,000 increase in net cemetery and mortuary sales, and a$50,000 increase in other revenue. This increase in total revenues was partially offset by a$1,039,000 decrease in realized gains on investments and other assets, a$367,000 increase in other than temporary impairments, and a$241,000 decrease in insurance premiums and other considerations. Insurance premiums and other consideration decreased by$241,000 , or 0.5%, to$48,216,000 for 2012, from$48,457,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This decrease was primarily due to a decrease in renewal premiums due to the decline of older blocks of business, which was offset by an increase in first year premiums due to increased insurance sales. Net investment income increased by$3,239,000 , or 16.2%, to$23,250,000 for 2012, from$20,011,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was primarily attributable to a$2,461,000 increase in income from short-term investments, a$1,186,000 increase in income from real estate, a$378,000 decrease in investment expenses, and a$15,000 increase in interest on mortgage loans on real estate. This increase was partially offset by a$32,000 decrease in fixed maturity securities income, an$8,000 decrease in equity securities income, and a$5,000 decrease in policy loans income. 28 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Net cemetery and mortuary sales increased by$103,000 , or 1.0%, to$10,864,000 for 2012, from$10,761,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was primarily due to a$400,000 increase in cemetery pre-need and at-need sales, which was offset by a$297,000 decrease in mortuary at-need sales. Realized gains on investments and other assets decreased by$1,039,000 , or 42.2%, to$1,425,000 in realized gains for 2012, from$2,464,000 in realized gains for the comparable period in 2011. This decrease in realized gains and losses on investments and other assets is primarily due to the one-time gain of$887,000 on the sale ofGreer-Wilson Funeral Home andCrystal Rose Funeral Home that occurred in 2011, a$310,000 decrease in gains and losses on fixed maturity securities held to maturity, and an$85,000 decrease in gains and losses on securities available for sale. Other than temporary impairments on investments increased by$367,000 , or 43.6%, to$1,208,000 for 2012 from$841,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was due a$195,000 increase in impairments on securities available for sale, a$95,000 increase in impairments on mortgage loans on real estate, a$40,000 increase in impairments on fixed maturity securities held to maturity, and a$37,000 increase in impairments on other real estate owned held for investment. Mortgage fee income increased by$72,948,000 , or 94.0%, to$150,553,000 for 2012, from$77,605,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was primarily attributable to an increase in secondary gains on mortgage loans sold to investors and an increase in loan volume due to the expansion of the retail loan operations ofSecurityNational Mortgage .
Other revenues increased by
Total benefits and expenses were
Death benefits, surrenders and other policy benefits, and future policy benefits decreased by an aggregate of$523,000 or 1.1%, to$45,681,000 for 2012, from$46,204,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was primarily the result of a$93,000 increase in death benefits, a$207,000 increase in surrender and other policy benefits offset by a$823,000 decrease in future policy benefits. Amortization of deferred policy and pre-need acquisition costs and value of business acquired decreased by$320,000 , or 5.5%, to$5,449,000 for 2012, from$5,769,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This decrease was primarily due to improved persistency in the traditional life and universal life lines of business. Selling, general and administrative expenses increased by an aggregate of$53,796,000 , or 52.5%, to$156,310,000 for 2012, from$102,514,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was the result of an increase in commission expenses of$36,325,000 , fromin 2011 to $83,840,000 in 2012, due to an increase in sales in the mortgage operations, life operations and the cemetery operations. Other expenses increased by$7,253,000 from$25,157,000 in 2011 to$32,410,000 in 2012 primarily due to an increase in loan volume by the mortgage operations. Salaries increased by$5,358,000 from$23,531,000 in 2011 to$28,889,000 in 2012, primarily due to an increase in the number of employees. Costs related to funding mortgage loans increased by$2,691,000 from$4,240,000 in 2011 to$6,931,000 in 2012 due primarily to more loans funded as a result of increased demand in the housing sector. Provision for loan losses increased by$2,169,000 from$2,070,000 in 2011 to$4,239,000 in 2012, primarily due to an increase in monthly loan origination volume. Interest expense increased by$1,783,000 , or 90.9%, to$3,744,000 for 2012, from$1,961,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This increase was primarily due to increased outstanding balances on warehouse lines. Cost of goods and services sold of the cemeteries and mortuaries decreased by$159,000 , or 8.4%, to$1,724,000 for 2012, from$1,883,000 for the comparable period in 2011. This decrease was primarily due to a decrease in mortuary at-need sales, which was offset by an increase in cemetery pre-need and at-need sales. Other comprehensive income for the years endedDecember 31, 2012 andDecember 31, 2011 amounted to gains of$1,280,000 and a loss of$534,000 , respectively. This increase of$1,814,000 in 2012 was primarily the result a$1,503,000 increase in unrealized gains in securities available for sale, and a gain of$311,000 in derivatives related to mortgage loans. 29 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2011 Compared to 2010
Total revenues decreased by$8,943,000 , or 5.3%, to$159,567,000 for fiscal year 2011 from$168,510,000 for the fiscal year 2010. Contributing to this decrease in total revenues was a$19,737,000 decrease in mortgage fee income, a$759,000 decrease in net cemetery and mortuary sales, a$472,000 decrease in other revenue, and a$167,000 increase in other than temporary impairments. This decrease in total revenues was partially offset by a$9,948,000 increase in insurance premiums and other considerations, a$1,395,000 increase in net investment income, and an$849,000 increase in realized gains on investments and other assets. Insurance premiums and other consideration increased by$9,948,000 , or 25.8%, to$48,457,000 for 2011, from$38,509,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This increase was primarily due to the reinsurance transaction withNorth America Life that was completed inMarch 2011 , an increase in renewal premiums, and an increase in first year premiums due to increased insurance sales. Net investment income increased by$1,395,000 , or 7.5%, to$20,011,000 for 2011, from$18,616,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This increase was primarily attributable to a$1,002,000 increase in fixed maturity securities income, a$708,000 increase in interest on mortgage loans on real estate, a$700,000 increase in income from real estate, a$33,000 increase in income in equity securities, and a$26,000 decrease in investment expenses. This increase was partially offset by a$960,000 decrease in income from short-term investments, and by a$62,000 decrease in policy loan income. Net cemetery and mortuary sales decreased by$759,000 , or 6.6%, to$10,761,000 for 2011, from$11,520,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This reduction was primarily due to a decline in at-need sales of mortuary operations as a result of the sale of twoArizona funeral homes in 2011. Realized gains on investments and other assets increased by$849,000 , or 52.6%, to$2,464,000 in realized gains for 2011, from$1,615,000 in realized gains for the comparable period in 2010. This increase in realized gains on investments and other assets was primarily due to an$887,000 gain on the sale ofGreer-Wilson Funeral Home andCrystal Rose Funeral Home in 2011, which was partially offset by a decrease in realized gains on fixed maturity securities. Other than temporary impairments on investments increased by$167,000 , or 24.7%, to$841,000 for 2011 from$674,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This increase is due to impairments on other real estate owned held for investment offset by a decrease in impairments on fixed maturity securities held to maturity. Mortgage fee income decreased by$19,737,000 , or 20.3%, to$77,605,000 for 2011, from$97,342,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This decrease was primarily attributable to a decrease in secondary gains on mortgage loans sold to investors and a decrease in loan volume due to a reduced demand in the housing sector caused by the slow growth of the economy.
Other revenues decreased by
Total benefits and expenses were
Death benefits, surrenders and other policy benefits, and increase in future policy benefits increased by an aggregate of$8,258,000 or 21.8%, to$46,204,000 for 2011, from$37,946,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This increase was primarily the result of increased future policy benefits, increased death benefits, and increased surrender and other policy benefits primarily due to the reinsurance transaction withNorth America Life Insurance Company . Amortization of deferred policy and pre-need acquisition costs and value of business acquired increased by$1,338,000 , or 30.2%, to$5,769,000 for 2011, from$4,431,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This increase was primarily due to the reinsurance transaction withNorth America Life Insurance Company and an increase in business in force. Selling, general and administrative expenses decreased by an aggregate of$19,704,000 , or 16.1%, to$102,514,000 for 2011, from$122,218,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This decrease was the result of a reduction in commission expenses of$10,925,000 , from$58,440,000 in 2010 to$47,515,000 in 2011, due to a decrease in sales in the mortgage operations and the cemetery operations, which was partially offset by an increase in life insurance first year and renewal commissions during 2011. Salaries decreased by$2,875,000 from$26,406,000 in 2010 to$23,531,000 in 2011, primarily due to a reduction in the number of employee equivalents. Provision for loan losses decreased by$3,334,000 from$5,404,000 in 2010 to$2,070,000 in 2011, primarily due to a decrease in monthly loan origination volume and a reduction in investor demands due to previous settlements. Costs related to funding mortgage loans decreased by$1,804,000 from$6,044,000 in 2010 to$4,240,000 in 2011 due primarily to fewer loans funded as a result of reduced demand in the housing sector. Other expenses decreased by$766,000 from$25,923,000 in 2010 to$25,157,000 in 2011. 30 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Interest expense decreased by$818,000 , or 29.4%, to$1,961,000 for 2011, from$2,779,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This reduction was primarily due to decreased outstanding balances on warehouse lines. Cost of goods and services sold of the cemeteries and mortuaries decreased by$343,000 , or 15.4%, to$1,883,000 for 2011, from$2,226,000 for the comparable period in 2010. This decrease was primarily due to decreased at-need cemetery sales and mortuary sales. Other comprehensive income for the years endedDecember 31, 2011 andDecember 31, 2010 amounted to losses of$534,000 and$405,000 , respectively. This decrease of$129,000 in 2011 was primarily the result of a$1,123,000 decrease in unrealized gains in securities available for sale, and a gain of$994,000 in derivatives related to mortgage loans.
Risks
The following is a description of the most significant risks facing the Company and how it mitigates those risks:
Legal and Regulatory Risks - The risk that changes in the legal or regulatory environment in which the Company operates will create additional expenses and/or risks not anticipated by the Company in developing and pricing its products. That is, regulatory initiatives designed to reduce insurer profits, new legal theories or insurance company insolvencies through guaranty fund assessments may create costs for the insurer beyond those recorded in the consolidated financial statements. In addition, changes in tax law with respect to mortgage interest deductions or other public policy or legislative changes may affect the Company's mortgage sales. Also, the Company may be subject to further regulations in the cemetery/mortuary business. The Company mitigates these risks by offering a wide range of products and by diversifying its operations, thus reducing its exposure to any single product or jurisdiction, and also by employing underwriting practices which identify and minimize the adverse impact of such risks. Mortgage Industry Risks - Developments in the mortgage industry and credit markets adversely affected the Company's ability to sell certain of its mortgage loans to investors, which impacted the Company's financial results by requiring it to assume the risk of holding and servicing many of these loans. The mortgage loan loss reserve is an estimate of probable losses at the balance sheet date that the Company will realize in the future on mortgage loans sold to third party investors.SecurityNational Mortgage may be required to reimburse third party investors for costs associated with early payoff of loans within the first six months of such loans and to repurchase loans where there is a default in any of the first four monthly payments to the investors or, in lieu of repurchase, to pay a negotiated fee to the investors.SecurityNational Mortgage's estimates are based upon historical loss experience and the best estimate of the probable loan loss liabilities. Upon completion of a transfer that satisfies the conditions to be accounted for as a sale,SecurityNational Mortgage initially measures at fair value liabilities incurred in a sale relating to any guarantee or recourse provisions.SecurityNational Mortgage accrues a monthly allowance for indemnification losses to investors based onSecurityNational Mortgage's historical experience. The amounts accrued for loan losses in years endedDecember 31, 2012 , 2011 and 2010 were$4,053,000 ,$1,668,000 and$4,534,000 , respectively, and the charge to expense has been included in selling, general and administrative expenses. The estimated liability for indemnification losses is included in other liabilities and accrued expenses and, as ofDecember 31, 2012 and 2011, the balances were$6,035,000 and$2,338,000 , respectively. The Company believes the allowance for loan losses and the loan loss reserve represent probable loan losses incurred as ofDecember 31, 2012 . However, there is a risk that future loan losses may exceed the loan loss reserves and allowances. As ofDecember 31, 2012 , the Company's long term mortgage loan portfolio consisted of$11,679,000 in mortgage loans with delinquencies more than 90 days. Of this amount,$6,039,000 of the loans were in foreclosure proceedings. The Company has not received or recognized any interest income on the$11,679,000 in mortgage loans with delinquencies more than 90 days. During the twelve months endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011,SecurityNational Mortgage increased its allowance for mortgage losses by$434,000 and$1,236,000 , respectively, which was charged to loan loss expense and is included in selling, general and administrative expenses for the period. The allowances for mortgage loan losses as ofDecember 31, 2012 and 2011 were$4,240,000 and$4,881,000 , respectively. 31 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- There have been assertions in third party investor correspondence thatSecurityNational Mortgage sold mortgage loans that allegedly contained misrepresentations or experienced early payment defaults, or that were otherwise allegedly defective or not in compliance with agreements betweenSecurityNational Mortgage and the third party investors consisting principally of financial institutions. As a result of these claims, third party investors have made demands thatSecurityNational Mortgage repurchase certain alleged defective mortgage loans that were sold to such investors or indemnify them against any losses related to such loans. The total amount of potential claims and notices of potential claims are greater than the net asset value ofSecurityNational Mortgage , which was$26,835,000 onDecember 31, 2012 , and its reserve for mortgage loan loss, which was$6,035,000 onDecember 31, 2012 .SecurityNational Mortgage disagrees with the claims and notices of potential claims asserted by third party investors against it and believes it has significant defenses to these claims. Any additional losses in excess of the current loan loss reserve cannot be estimated asSecurityNational Mortgage is currently in the process of reviewing repurchase demands and notices of potential claims from third party investors. IfSecurityNational Mortgage is unable to resolve demands by the third party investors on acceptable terms, legal action may ensue in an effort to obtain amounts that the third party investors claim are allegedly due. In the event of legal action, ifSecurityNational Mortgage is not successful in its defenses against claims asserted by these third party investors to the extent that a substantial judgment is entered againstSecurityNational Mortgage which is beyond its capacity to pay,SecurityNational Mortgage may be required to curtail or cease operations. Also atDecember 31, 2012 , the Company had foreclosed on a total of$60,710,000 in long term mortgage loans, of which$17,020,000 of the loans foreclosed were reclassified as other real estate held for investment or sale during 2012. The Company carries the foreclosed properties in Security National Life,Memorial Estates , andSecurityNational Mortgage , its respective life, cemeteries and mortuaries, and mortgage subsidiaries, and will rent the properties until it is deemed economically desirable to sell them. Interest Rate Risk - the risk that interest rates will change which may cause a decrease in the value of the Company's investments or impair the ability of the Company to market its mortgage and cemetery/mortuary products. This change in rates may cause certain interest-sensitive products to become uncompetitive or may cause disintermediation. The Company mitigates this risk by charging fees for non-conformance with certain policy provisions, by offering products that transfer this risk to the purchaser, and/or by attempting to match the maturity schedule of its assets with the expected payouts of its liabilities. To the extent that liabilities come due more quickly than assets mature, the Company might have to borrow funds or sell assets prior to maturity and potentially recognize a loss on the sale. Mortality/Morbidity Risk - the risk that the Company's actuarial assumptions may differ from actual mortality/morbidity experience may cause the Company's products to be underpriced, may cause the Company to liquidate insurance or other claims earlier than anticipated and other potentially adverse consequences to the business. The Company minimizes this risk through sound underwriting practices, asset/liability duration matching, and sound actuarial practices. Estimates - The preparation of financial statements in conformity with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles requires management to make estimates and assumptions that affect the amounts reported in the consolidated financial statements and accompanying notes. Actual results could differ from those estimates. The estimates susceptible to significant change are those used in determining the liability for future policy benefits and claims, those used in determining valuation allowances for mortgage loans on real estate, construction loans, estimate of probable loan loss reserve, and other receivables, and those used in determining the estimated future costs for pre-need sales. Although some variability is inherent in these estimates, management believes the amounts provided are adequate.
Liquidity and Capital Resources
The Company's life insurance subsidiaries and cemetery and mortuary subsidiaries realize cash flow from premiums, contract payments and sales on personal services rendered for cemetery and mortuary business, from interest and dividends on invested assets, and from the proceeds from the maturity of held to maturity investments or sale of other investments. The mortgage subsidiary realizes cash flow from fees generated by originating and refinancing mortgage loans and interest earned on mortgages sold to investors. The Company considers these sources of cash flow to be adequate to fund future policyholder and cemetery and mortuary liabilities, which generally are long-term, and adequate to pay current policyholder claims, annuity payments, expenses on the issuance of new policies, the maintenance of existing policies, debt service, and to meet operating expenses. 32
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- During the twelve months endedDecember 31, 2012 and 2011, the Company's operations provided cash of$22,416,000 and$6,866,000 , respectively. This was due primarily to an$18,808,000 increase in 2012 and an increase of$15,145,000 in 2011 in the balance of mortgage loans sold to investors and a$12,086,000 increase in 2012 and an$830,000 decrease in 2011 in other liabilities. The Company's liability for future life, annuity and other benefits is expected to be paid out over long-term due to the Company's market niche of selling funeral plans. Funeral plans are small face value life insurance that will pay the costs and expenses incurred at the time of a person's death. A person generally will keep these policies in force and will not surrender them prior to a person's death. Because of the long-term nature of these liabilities the Company is able to hold to maturity its bonds, real estate and mortgage loans thus reducing the risk of liquidating these long-term investments as a result of any sudden changes in market values. The Company attempts to match the duration of invested assets with its policyholder and cemetery and mortuary liabilities. The Company may sell investments other than those held to maturity in the portfolio to help in this timing. The Company purchases short-term investments on a temporary basis to meet the expectations of short-term requirements of the Company's products. The Company's investment philosophy is intended to provide a rate of return, which will persist during the expected duration of policyholder and cemetery and mortuary liabilities regardless of future interest rate movements. The Company's investment policy is to invest predominantly in fixed maturity securities, mortgage loans, and warehousing of mortgage loans on a short-term basis before selling the loans to investors in accordance with the requirements and laws governing the life insurance subsidiaries. Bonds owned by the insurance subsidiaries amounted to$127,939,000 as ofDecember 31, 2012 compared to$126,068,000 as ofDecember 31, 2011 . This represents 36.9% and 37.9% of the total investments as ofDecember 31, 2012 , andDecember 31, 2011 , respectively. Generally, all bonds owned by the life insurance subsidiaries are rated by theNational Association of Insurance Commissioners . Under this rating system, there are six categories used for rating bonds. AtDecember 31, 2012 , 3.4% (or$4,392,000 ) and atDecember 31, 2011 , 4.1% (or$5,182,000 ) of the Company's total bond investments were invested in bonds in rating categories three through six, which are considered non-investment grade. The Company has classified certain of its fixed income securities, including high-yield securities, in its portfolio as available for sale, with the remainder classified as held to maturity. However, in accordance with Company policy, any such securities purchased in the future will be classified as held to maturity. Business conditions, however, may develop in the future which may indicate a need for a higher level of liquidity in the investment portfolio. In that event the Company believes it could sell short-term investment grade securities before liquidating higher yielding longer-term securities.
See Note 2 of the Notes to Consolidated Financial Statements for the schedule of the maturity of fixed maturity securities and for the schedule of principal payments for mortgage loans on real estate and construction loans held for investment.
If market conditions were to cause interest rates to change, the market value of the fixed income portfolio (of approximately$234,919,000 ) could change by the following amounts based on the respective basis point swing (the change in the market values were calculated using a modeling technique): -200 bps -100 bps +100 bps +200 bps Change in Market Value (in thousands) $ 18,360 $ 9,617 $ (12,945 ) $ (23,179 ) The Company is subject to risk based capital guidelines established by statutory regulators requiring minimum capital levels based on the perceived risk of assets, liabilities, disintermediation, and business risk. AtDecember 31, 2012 , andDecember 31, 2011 , the life insurance subsidiaries exceeded the regulatory criteria. The Company's total capitalization of stockholders' equity, and bank debt and notes payable were$91,722,000 as ofDecember 31, 2012 , as compared to$86,250,000 as ofDecember 31, 2011 . Stockholders' equity as a percent of total capitalization was 87.0% and 71.0% as ofDecember 31, 2012 andDecember 31, 2011 , respectively. Bank debt and notes payable decreased$13,109,000 for the twelve months endedDecember 31, 2012 when compared toDecember 31, 2011 , thus increasing the stockholders equity percentage. 33 --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lapse rates measure the amount of insurance terminated during a particular period. The Company's lapse rate for life insurance in 2012 was 6.0% as compared to a rate of 6.5% for 2011.
AtDecember 31, 2012 ,$32,992,000 of the Company's consolidated stockholders' equity represents the statutory stockholders' equity of the Company's life insurance subsidiaries. The life insurance subsidiaries cannot pay a dividend to its parent company without the approval of insurance regulatory authorities.
Forward-Looking Statements
The Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995 provides a safe harbor for forward-looking statements to encourage companies to provide prospective information about their businesses without fear of litigation so long as those statements are identified as forward-looking and are accompanied by meaningful cautionary statements identifying important factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in such statements. The Company desires to take advantage of the "safe harbor" provisions of the act. This Annual Report on Form 10-K contains forward-looking statements, together with related data and projections, about the Company's projected financial results and its future plans and strategies. However, actual results and needs of the Company may vary materially from forward-looking statements and projections made from time to time by the Company on the basis of management's then-current expectations. The business in which the Company is engaged involves changing and competitive markets, which may involve a high degree of risk, and there can be no assurance that forward-looking statements and projections will prove accurate. Factors that may cause the Company's actual results to differ materially from those contemplated or projected, forecast, estimated or budgeted in such forward looking statements include among others, the following possibilities: (i) heightened competition, including the intensification of price competition, the entry of new competitors, and the introduction of new products by new and existing competitors; (ii) adverse state and federal legislation or regulation, including decreases in rates, limitations on premium levels, increases in minimum capital and reserve requirements, benefit mandates and tax treatment of insurance products; (iii) fluctuations in interest rates causing a reduction of investment income or increase in interest expense and in the market value of interest rate sensitive investment; (iv) failure to obtain new customers, retain existing customers or reductions in policies in force by existing customers; (v) higher service, administrative, or general expense due to the need for additional advertising, marketing, administrative or management information systems expenditures; (vi) loss or retirement of key executives or employees; (vii) increases in medical costs; (viii) changes in the Company's liquidity due to changes in asset and liability matching; (ix) restrictions on insurance underwriting based on genetic testing and other criteria; (x) adverse changes in the ratings obtained by independent rating agencies; (xi) failure to maintain adequate reinsurance; (xii) possible claims relating to sales practices for insurance products and claim denials and (xiii) adverse trends in mortality and morbidity; (xiv) deterioration of real estate markets and (xv) lawsuits in the ordinary course of business. Off-Balance Sheet Agreements AtDecember 31, 2012 , the Company was contingently liable under a standby letter of credit aggregating$458,224 , to be used as collateral to cover any contingency related to additional risk assessments pertaining to the Company's self-insurance casualty program. The Company does not expect any material losses to result from the issuance of the standby letter of credit because claims are not expected to exceed premiums paid. Accordingly, the estimated fair value of these instruments is zero. AtDecember 31, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage was contingently liable under a standby letter of credit aggregating$1,250,000 , to be used as collateral to cover any contingency related to claims filed in states whereSecurityNational Mortgage is licensed.SecurityNational Mortgage does not expect any material losses to result from the issuance of the standby letter of credit. Accordingly, the estimated fair value of these instruments is zero.SecurityNational Mortgage has entered into loan purchase agreements to originate and sell mortgage loans to two unaffiliated warehouse banks. OnMarch 19, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage andWells Fargo Bank, N.A. ("Wells Fargo") entered into a loan purchase agreement in which Wells Fargo agreed to provide a warehouse line of up to$55,000,000 to fund certain approved mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage . OnAugust 6, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage and Wells Fargo agreed to an amendment to theMarch 19, 2012 loan purchase agreement to increase the amount of the warehouse line available to fund mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage from$55,000,000 to$75,000,000 . 34
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- OnJuly 16, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage andUBS Real Estate Securities Inc. ("UBS") entered into a loan purchase agreement in which UBS agreed to provide a warehouse line of up to$30,000,000 to fund mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage . OnOctober 26, 2012 ,SecurityNational Mortgage and UBS agreed to an amendment to theJuly 16, 2012 loan purchase agreement to increase the amount of the warehouse line available to fund mortgage loans originated bySecurityNational Mortgage from$30,000,000 to$40,000,000 .
As of
The total of the Company unfunded residential construction loan commitments as of
Contractual Obligations
The Company's contractual obligations as of
Less than over 1 year 1-3 years 4-5 years 5 years Total Non-cancelable
operating leases
Notes and
contracts
payable 6,266,765 5,435,939 161,704 45,935 11,910,343 $ 8,509,664 $ 9,449,806 $ 1,119,635 $ 59,732 $ 19,138,837 Variable Interest Entities In conjunction with the Company's casualty insurance program, limited equity interests are held in a captive insurance entity. This program permits the Company to self-insure a portion of losses, to gain access to a wide array of safety-related services, to pool insurance risks and resources in order to obtain more competitive pricing for administration and reinsurance and to limit its risk of loss in any particular year. This entity meets the definition of a variable interest entity (VIE); however, under generally accepted accounting principles, "there is not a requirement to include this entity in the consolidated financial statements." The maximum exposure to loss related to the Company's involvement with this entity is limited to approximately$458,224 , a majority of which is collateralized under a standby letter of credit issued on the insurance entity's behalf. See Note 9, "Reinsurance, Commitments and Contingencies," for additional discussion of commitments associated with the insurance program and Note 1, "Significant Accounting Policies", for further information on a standby letter of credit. As ofDecember 31, 2012 , there are no other entities that met the definition of a variable interest entity.
Wordcount: | 13785 |
Advisor News
Annuity News
Health/Employee Benefits News
Life Insurance News