Wisconsin basketball’s 2023-24 season came to a crashing end with a 72-61 loss to James Madison on Friday night.
The loss delivered another year of postseason failure for the Badgers and left many questioning Gard’s future as the team’s head coach. Seven years have passed since the program’s last Sweet 16 appearance, and it has only two tournament wins in that time span.
Related: Evaluating the reasons for and against Wisconsin basketball firing head coach Greg Gard
Wisconsin athletic director Chris McIntosh will have some tough decisions to make this offseason. On one hand, the lack of postseason success is certainly troubling. On the other hand, firing Gard would be a seismic move and could create more questions than answers. The Badgers are in position to return a wealth of talent in 2024-25 — and firing Gard could lead to more of a mini-rebuild than fans want to admit.
Everyone can agree that any move off Gard must include a clear plan for the next head coach. There are big names out there, but Wisconsin must know that those names are attainable before it makes a big move.
If McIntosh is to fire Gard, here are 15 possible replacements:
1
Jay Wright
Current: CBS analyst
Record: 642-282 (122-85 at Hofstra, 520-197 at Villanova)
Some of these names are unrealistic, but must be included. Jay Wright fits into that category.
The all-time great head coach is in a fantastic situation doing television and avoiding the day-to-day grind of coaching. But there’s always the chance he wants to return to coaching. That return would immediately make him the No. 1 option on every team’s board.
McIntosh shot for the stars with the Luke Fickell hire, why not give Jay Wright a call.
2
Tony Bennett
Current: Virginia
Record: 433-169 (364-136 at Virginia, 69-33 at Washington State)
Tony Bennett’s connection to Wisconsin is an easy one: He’s the son of former Badgers head coach Dick Bennett.
The question is would Bennett leave Virginia for a program like Wisconsin. He has proven the ability to consistently win at Virginia and has all the necessary resources to continue to do so.
Also, Bennett’s name has lost a bit of luster with Virginia’s recent struggles. Also, it would be surprising if Wisconsin moved off Gard to implement an even slower offensive system.
3
T.J. Otzelberger
Current: Iowa State
Record: 169-97 (70-34 at Iowa State, 29-30 at Nevada-Las Vegas, 70-33 at South Dakota State)
Otzelberger is one of the hottest names in the college coaching market. He has Iowa State in the Sweet 16 and playing like one of the best teams in the country.
His defensive-first approach could appeal to Wisconsin’s brass. Plus, he is already having success recruiting the state of Wisconsin — something Gard or the next coach must improve upon.
Otzelberger would be a home-run hire. The question is whether he’d leave Iowa State for a possible Wisconsin opening.
4
Joe Krabbenhoft
Current: Wisconsin (assistant)
Record: Zero head coaching experience
Any coaching candidate list must include the possible internal promotion, which would be Krabbenhoft.
The former Wisconsin small forward has been on Greg Gard’s staff since 2016 and, obviously, knows the program well.
I’d bet against this happening given the need for a home run hire if Gard is fired. Krabbenhoft may make a good coach, but he isn’t the name that would revitalize the fan base.
5
Nate Oats
Current: Alabama
Record: 210-96 (114-53 at Alabama, 96-43 at Buffalo)
Oats has turned Alabama, a football school, into one of the SEC’s best and most consistent basketball programs. The Crimson Tide have made four consecutive NCAA Tournaments — after making only two from 2007-2020.
Oats is also a Wisconsin native and was an assistant coach at UW-Whitewater from 2000-2002. The in-state connection could be easily sold.
Wisconsin is a better job than Alabama and should be attractive enough for Oats to leave his current post. This would be a big-time hire.
6
John Beilein
Current: Detroit Pistons (advisor)
Record: 571-325 (278-150 at Michigan, 104-60 at West Virginia, 100-53 at Richmond, 89-62 at Canisius)
Beilein is one of the more decorated names in the college coaching profession. Like Wright, he may not want to return to the profession. But his name will come up as long as there are open jobs.
The longtime Michigan coach left college after the 2019 season for an NBA job, so there is a question whether his methods would still work. His ability as a coach is without question. The hesitation would be his recruiting ability in the current age.
It’s hard seeing someone with deep Michigan ties taking the Wisconsin job, but you never know.
7
Lamont Paris
Current: South Carolina
Record: 124-101 (37-29 at South Carolina, 87-72 at Chattanooga)
Paris should be toward the top of the list. The former Wisconsin assistant was named 2024 SEC Coach of the Year after the team’s surprising 26-8 season.
Paris spent 2010-2017 as an assistant on Bo Ryan and Greg Gard’s Wisconsin coaching staffs. He left to get head coaching experience. That has quickly led to him becoming one of the hottest names in the profession.
The young head coach just signed an extension with South Carolina. But the modern age of college athletics sees those types of things not really matter.
8
Chris Collins
Current: Northwestern
Record: 178-173 (all at Northwestern)
Collins has turned Northwestern into a solid program — peaking in 2022-23 and 2023-24 with NCAA Tournament appearances.
This would be tough to see happening given Collins’ current Big Ten position. But it would be a solid hire.
9
Niko Medved
Current: Colorado State
Record: 196-163 (117-75 at Colorado State, 17-17 at Drake, 62-71 at Furman)
Medved is one of the fastest-rising names in the profession. He built Colorado State into a staple in the Mountain West and is an exceptional talent-developer.
Wisconsin’s brand is built on what Medved has proven good at. So this should be a solid fit.
10
Kyle Smith
Current: Washington State
Record: 258-193 (94-71 at Washington State, 63-40 at San Francisco, 101-82 at Columbia)
Smith wins everywhere he goes and impressively led Washington State to a 25-10 record and NCAA Tournament appearance in 2023-24.
His name is sure to gain traction as time passes.
UPDATE: Kyle Smith recently took the job at Stanford.
11
Darian DeVries
Current: Drake
Record: 150-55 (all at Drake)
DeVries has turned Drake into a Missouri Valley powerhouse with at least 24 wins in five of his six years at the helm.
This portion of the big board is mostly-up-and-coming coaches in the sport — like Luke Fickell was in football before he made the jump to Wisconsin.
Note: DeVries was hired by West Virginia on Sunday, March 24. A 15th name has been added to the end of the list.
12
Josh Schertz
Current: Indiana State
Record: 63-39 (all at Indiana State)
Schertz is only three years into his head coaching career, but he’s already turned Indiana State into a power in the Missouri Valley Conference. His offensive acumen would be a welcome sight for Badgers fans looking for change.
13
Drew Valentine
Current: Loyola (Chicago)
Record: 58-39 (all at Loyola Chicago)
Valentine has extensive Michigan State ties, but he’s one of the newest top up-and-coming names in the sport. His team won the A-10 regular season title in 2023-24 in his third year on the job. That feat came after winning 25 games in his first year, 2021-22.
14
Chris Mack
Current: Not coaching
Record: 278-133 (63-36 at Louisville, 215-97 at Xavier)
Mack was a turnstile winner at Xavier from 2009-2018 before leaving for Louisville. His tenure with the Cardinals was short, and he hasn’t coached in a few years, but a return to the profession could see him entered as a hot coaching candidate.
15
Danny Sprinkle
Current: Utah State
Record: 109-49 (28-6 at Utah State, 81-43 at Montana State)
Sprinkle’s name is hot after his first year at Utah State resulted in a 28-6 record and NCAA Tournament appearance. His ties are all to the West Coast, but he would make an exciting hire for the Badgers.
UPDATE: Sprinkle was recently hired by Washington
16
Greg McDermott
Current: Creighton
Record: 474-290 (325-159 at Creighton, 59-68 at Iowa State, 90-63 at Northern Iowa)
McDermott is a mainstay at Creighton. He has brought the Blue Jays to four straight NCAA Tournaments and nine straight 20-plus-win seasons. He’s in a great situation and having success, but maybe he eventually wants an upgrade.
17
Analysis
Many of the names listed are unlikely, mostly given the unknown of Wisconsin’s place in the sport and what Chris McIntosh wants in a head coach. But Wisconsin will not fire Greg Gard without a top name set up to take the position, so there’s no point in listing middling names that wouldn’t move the needle.
T.J. Otzelberger feels like the slam-dunk hire if it’s at all possible. I have trouble coming up with rankings after that.
18
Follow Badgers Wire
Contact/Follow @TheBadgersWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Wisconsin Badgers news, notes and opinion. Follow Ben Kenney on X.