If you're a fan of single-serve coffee makers, your choice typically comes down to two main brands that dominate the space: Nespresso vs. Keurig. When they first came out, Keurig machines were solely for coffee, while Nespresso machines focused exclusively on espresso. However, over the years, both brands have expanded their capabilities and product ranges. Today, both pod coffee makers offer similar features, which can make it tricky to decide which option is right for your morning cup of joe.
In the debate of Nespresso vs. Keurig, there's no clear-cut winner—both brands excel in specific ... [+]
To help you in finding the best coffee maker for your kitchen, we've extensively tested numerous top-rated Nespresso and Keurig models, evaluating them based on features, performance and value. Here's what you need to know about Nespresso vs. Keurig machines and how to select the one that suits your preferences.
Nespresso Vs. Keurig: Which Is Better?
The coffee makers from both brands offer fast and convenient brewing, yet there are several key distinctions between Nespresso and Keurig machines. The details may vary depending on the specific models you're considering, but in general, here's how the brands compare in terms of brewing, beverage variety, ease of use and cost.
Brewing Method
Keurig coffee makers function similarly to standard drip coffee machines but on a smaller scale. When you insert a K-cup into the machine, it punctures several holes in the top and bottom of the pod. The machine then heats water from its reservoir to approximately 192 degrees Fahrenheit and employs an air pump to force the hot water into the K-cup.
The K-cup essentially serves as the brewing chamber, allowing the water to mix with the coffee grounds before dispensing into your awaiting cup. The entire process typically lasts from one to three minutes, and more advanced Keurig models offer options to adjust the water temperature and/or brew strength to cater to your preferences.
On the other hand, Nespresso machines—particularly those in the Vertuo line—employ a different brewing method. The brand utilizes its distinctive brewing technology known as "Centrifusion," which entails spinning the capsule in a centrifugal action. During brewing, water is injected into the dome-shaped pod, which is then spun at speeds up to 7,000 rotations per minute. This results in thorough saturation of the coffee grounds and the creation of Nespresso's signature crema on top of your drink. With a Nespresso machine, it typically takes less than a minute to brew espresso and around two minutes for a cup of coffee.
It's important to note that Centrifusion technology is exclusive to Nespresso Vertuo machines. Nespresso's original line of espresso makers utilizes a high-pressure 19-bar extraction system, similar to Keurig's method.
Variety Of Brews
When it comes to beverage variety, Keurig stands out as the more versatile option. With hundreds of K-cup pods available, sourced from over 40 brands like Dunkin, Starbucks, Green Mountain Coffee Roasters and even McCafé from McDonald's, the selection is extensive.
Keurig machines also offer a diverse range of drinks beyond hot coffee. There are K-cups for iced tea, iced coffee, hot chocolate, herbal tea and other specialty beverages. Additionally, the brand provides a reusable K-cup that allows you to fill it with your preferred coffee grounds, eliminating the need to purchase single-use pods altogether.
On the other hand, Nespresso's selection is more limited. With approximately 45 types of Vertuo capsules available, including options for espresso and coffee, the choices are fewer. However, Nespresso machines cannot brew other specialty drinks like tea or hot cocoa.
For enthusiasts of milk-based drinks such as lattes and cappuccinos, both Nespresso and Keurig offer models with built-in milk frothers, enabling you to create coffee shop-style beverages at home.
Ease Of Use
The main appeal of both Keurig and Nespresso coffee machines lies in their quick and easy usability. You simply pop in a pod, select your settings and hit brew. In a matter of minutes (or even seconds), your beverage is dispensed into your waiting mug.
However, there are noteworthy differences between the two brands. With basic Keurig machines, you may need to manually adjust settings for a stronger brew or hotter water temperature. Some base models may not offer these adjustments at all. Nonetheless, Keurig's Wi-Fi connected models can scan the QR code on each K-cup and automatically optimize the brew settings.
In contrast, all Nespresso Vertuo machines scan the barcode on the capsule to set brewing parameters automatically. This includes adjusting the cup size, temperature, rotational speed, flow rate and brew time for optimal extraction. Additionally, most Nespresso machines feature built-in storage containers for used capsules, eliminating the need for manual removal after each brew, as required with a Keurig.
Design
If aesthetics are a priority for you, Nespresso machines typically offer a more attractive and modern design. They often feature luxe finishes, metallic accents and sleek silhouettes. Some high-end models even boast stainless steel exteriors, adding a touch of elegance to your kitchen counter. Additionally, Nespresso capsules themselves are aesthetically pleasing, featuring a pretty metallic exterior.
On the contrary, Keurig machines often feature a more simplistic design. The machine is predominantly crafted from plastic with a matte finish, and the "metallic" accents are typically made using silver plastic rather than authentic metal. Additionally, Keurig coffee makers tend to have a larger footprint, giving them a bulkier appearance compared to Nespresso machines.
Cost
When discussing Nespresso vs. Keurig machines, price is a significant factor to consider. If you're seeking a budget-friendly option, Keurig emerges as the clear winner. Its machines typically range from $80 to around $300, with most full-size models falling within the $100–$150 range. Additionally, Keurig pods are generally more affordable, priced as low as $0.35 per K-cup. Moreover, you have the flexibility to invest in a reusable pod, eliminating the need to purchase K-cups altogether.
On the contrary, Nespresso machines tend to be pricier. The most affordable Nespresso models start at around $120, while the brand's most luxurious models can reach upward of $800. Similarly, Nespresso capsules come with a higher price tag, starting at approximately $0.98 per piece. Additionally, there's no option for a reusable capsule officially sanctioned by the brand.
Best Nespresso Machines
If you’re sold on Nespresso luxurious designs and advanced brewing technology, we've rigorously tested many of the brand's top-rated models. Here are our top picks for the best Nespresso machines.
Best Keurig Machines
For a broader selection of drink options and a lower overall investment, opting for one of the best Keurig coffee makers might be the ideal choice for your kitchen. Here are several top-performing models that we highly recommend.
Final Verdict
In the debate of Nespresso vs. Keurig, there's no clear-cut winner—both brands excel in specific areas, making it a matter of which option aligns best with your preferences and needs.
If you prioritize superior drink flavor, Nespresso is likely the better choice. Thanks to its centrifugal brewing style, Nespresso Vertuo machines produce a richer, more flavorful drink with a thick layer of crema. Additionally, Nespresso machines are typically sleeker and more compact. However, it's important to note that Nespresso machines come with a higher price tag and offer fewer drink options.
On the other hand, for those who value drink variety and affordability, Keurig is the preferred option. With hundreds of K-cup options available and typically more budget-friendly capsules than Nespresso, Keurig offers greater versatility. The coffee makers themselves are also generally lower in price. However, the downside of Keurig machines is the bulkier design and the potential for less flavorful brews compared to Nespresso.
Why Trust Forbes Vetted
The Forbes Vetted team has extensive experience testing coffee makers (and drinking coffee!), so we know what makes a great cup of joe. We’ve tried out the best drip coffee makers and espresso machines, and we’ve also reviewed many of the most popular Nespresso and Keurig models available on that market today. We evaluated these single-serve coffee makers on factors such as flavor, ease of use, design and value, helping you to select the best option to add to your morning routine.
Is Nespresso Better Than Keurig?
Nespresso machines hold an advantage over Keurig coffee makers in several key areas. Notably, Nespresso models often boast a more stylish and aesthetically pleasing design. Additionally, the brand's Vertuo line incorporates a more advanced brewing system. Rather than simply utilizing air pressure to force water through the capsules, the Centrifusion technology used by Nespresso spins the pods at high speeds. This process ensures more thorough saturation of the coffee grounds, resulting in enhanced flavor extraction and the creation of Nespresso's signature crema.
However, Keurigs excel in specific areas, particularly drink variety and cost-effectiveness. While Nespresso machines are limited to brewing coffee and espresso, Keurig offers an extensive selection of K-cup options from numerous brands, encompassing beverages such as hot chocolate, herbal tea and iced coffee. Moreover, Keurig machines and pods tend to be more budget-friendly, and the brand also offers a reusable K-cup option.
