Skip to main contentSkip to navigationSkip to key eventsSkip to navigation

Kamala Harris calls Trump ‘architect of healthcare crisis’ in Arizona abortion speech – as it happened

This live blog is now closed

 Updated 
Fri 12 Apr 2024 18.54 EDTFirst published on Fri 12 Apr 2024 09.07 EDT
Vice-president Kamala Harris speaks on reproductive freedom at El Rio Neighborhood center in Tucson, Arizona.
Vice-president Kamala Harris speaks on reproductive freedom at El Rio Neighborhood center in Tucson, Arizona. Photograph: Frederic J Brown/AFP/Getty Images
Vice-president Kamala Harris speaks on reproductive freedom at El Rio Neighborhood center in Tucson, Arizona. Photograph: Frederic J Brown/AFP/Getty Images

Live feed

Key events

Here is the list of the 86 House Republicans who voted against Arizona’s Republican representative Andy Biggs’ amendment to Fisa’s section 702 which called for the prohibition of warrantless surveillance:

NEW: 86 Republicans just voted against @RepAndyBiggsAZ’s amendment to require a warrant to spy on Americans under FISA causing it to fail.

Here are the names: pic.twitter.com/6mAoJfnlac

— Greg Price (@greg_price11) April 12, 2024

The Minnesota Democratic representative Ilhan Omar has criticized the House’s passage of the reauthorization of Fisa.

In a series of tweets on Friday, Omar, who voted against the legislation, wrote:

Section 702 still allows the government to collect communications of non-Americans abroad without a warrant. This has enabled warrantless surveillance that disproportionately targets Muslim Americans, African Americans, and other minority communities.

This has enabled warrantless surveillance that disproportionately targets Muslim Americans, African Americans, and other minority communities.

In 2022, the FBI exploited Section 702 more than 200,000 times to search for Americans' data.

This raises serious 4th Amendment…

— Rep. Ilhan Omar (@Ilhan) April 12, 2024

She went on to add:

True reform of surveillance powers needs warrants for searches of Americans, strict rules against racial and religious profiling [and] oversight to protect civil liberties.

Anything less continues a system used to unfairly target Americans under the guise of counterterrorism.

Share
Updated at 

Fisa bill's House passage proves a crucial victory for Mike Johnson

The 273-147 bipartisan vote reauthorizing Fisa is a win for the embattled House speaker, Mike Johnson, and comes at a time when he faces direct challenges to his leadership.

Johnson was seen on the House floor speaking to the far-right Georgia congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene, who last month filed a motion to remove Johnson from the speakership.

Greene later told reporters she and Johnson spoke about “all sorts of things”, CNN reported.

Johnson said he and Greene “agree on our conservative philosophy”, adding:

We just have different ideas sometimes on strategy. The important part of governing in a time of divided government like we have is communication with members and understanding the thought process behind it, that they have a say in it.

Johnson is also scheduled to meet with Donald Trump in Florida later on Friday.

Share
Updated at 
Nick Robins-Early

The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, or Fisa, which gives the government expansive powers to view emails, calls and texts, has long been divisive and resulted in allegations from civil liberties groups that it violates privacy rights.

Section 702 has faced opposition before, but it became especially fraught in the past year after court documents revealed that the FBI had improperly used it almost 300,000 times – targeting racial justice protesters, January 6 suspects and others. That overreach emboldened resistance to the law, especially among far-right Republicans who view intelligence services like the FBI as their opponent.

Debate over Section 702 pitted Republicans who alleged that the law was a tool for spying on American citizens against others in the GOP who sided with intelligence officials and deemed it a necessary measure to stop foreign terrorist groups.

One proposed amendment called for requiring authorities to secure a warrant before using section 702 to view US citizens’ communications, an idea that intelligence officials oppose as limiting their ability to act quickly.

Another sticking point in the debate was whether law enforcement should be prohibited from buying information on American citizens from data broker firms, which amass and sell personal data on tens of millions of people, including phone numbers and email addresses.

Share
Updated at 

Conservatives strike deal with Johnson to get Fisa bill passed

House conservatives who had blocked the Fisa bill earlier this week amid a push from Donald Trump allowed it to move forward on Friday after striking a deal with the speaker, Mike Johnson.

Under the agreement, the new version of the bill would be a two-year reauthorization of section 702 of Fisa, cut down from the original proposed five years.

This would mean that if Trump won the presidential election this year, the legislation would be up in time for Trump to overhaul Fisa laws next time around.

The far-right Florida Republican Matt Gaetz, speaking to CNN earlier today, said:

We just bought President Trump an at bat. The previous version of this bill would have kicked reauthorization beyond the Trump presidency. Now President Trump gets an at bat to fix the system that victimized him more than any other American.

Share
Updated at 

Two-year reauthorization of Fisa passes in House, 273-147

The House passed a two-year reauthorization of the nation’s warrantless surveillance program that had stalled earlier this week amid Republican resistance and after Donald Trump had urged GOP members to “kill” the law.

In a 273 to 147 vote, lawmakers renewed section 702 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (Fisa), which is set to expire on 19 April, through 2026. The bill now heads to the Senate, which is expected to give it bipartisan approval.

Section 702 allows the US government to collect the communications of targeted foreigners abroad by compelling service providers to produce copies of messages and internet data, or networks to intercept and turn over phone call and message data.

But the law is controversial because it allows the government to incidentally collect messages and phone data of Americans without a court order if they interacted with the foreign target, even though the law prohibits section 702 from being used by the NSA to specifically target US citizens.

The White House, intelligence chiefs and top lawmakers on the House intelligence committee have warned of potentially catastrophic effects of not reauthorizing the program.

Friday’s vote marks the fourth attempt to pass the bill, which was blocked three times in the past five months by House Republicans bucking their party. Earlier this week, House conservatives refused to support the bill that the speaker, Mike Johnson, put forward.

Share
Updated at 

The Republican Ohio congressman Warren Davidson, has responded to the House vote to reauthorize Fisa, calling it a “sad day’.

From Punchbowl news’ Mica Soellner:

Reacting to FISA bill passing without warrant, Rep. Warren Davidson says “it’s a pretty sad day”

Davidson led support on getting a warrant provision included and handed out buttons to members to express support

— Mica Soellner (@MicaSoellnerDC) April 12, 2024
Share
Updated at 

Fisa reauthorization passes in House

The House’s vote to reauthorize the Foreign Intelligence Service Act has passed.

Following days of Republican infighting that has put House Republican speaker Mike Johnson’s leadership in a precarious position, Fisa passed with a vote of 273 yays and 147 nays in the Republican-led chamber.

The vote marks a win for Johnson who has come under fire from hard-right Republicans including Georgia’s representative Marjorie Taylor Greene over his support for Fisa. Greene, who is opposed to Fisa, has repeatedly threatened to oust Johnson as he has “not lived up to a single one of his self-imposed tenets”.

With the vote’s passage, the reauthorization of Fisa, specifically its amendments to section 702, allows for intelligence officials to extend their warrantless surveillance on electronic communications between Americans and foreigners abroad.

Despite intelligence officials including the FBI director, Christopher Wray, arguing that a warrant requirement would “blind ourselves to intelligence in our holdings”, civil rights organizations such as the ACLU have criticized the legislation.

“Given our nation’s history of abusing its surveillance authorities, and the secrecy surrounding the program, we should be concerned that section 702 is and will be used to disproportionately target disfavored groups, whether minority communities, political activists, or even journalists,” it said.

Share
Updated at 

A vote to amend Fisa’s section 702 to update the definition of foreign intelligence to help target international narcotics trafficking has passed.

The amendment, introduced by Texas Republican representative Daniel Crenshaw, passed after 268 yays and 152 nays.

A vote to amend Fisa’s section 702 to require the FBI to report to Congress on the number of queries conducted on Americans has passed.

The amendment, introduced by Texas Republican representative Chip Roy, passed after 269 yays and 153 nays.

Most viewed

Most viewed