The cheapest full-coverage car insurance companies like USAA, Nationwide and Geico start at $119 per month on average.
Discover if you are overpaying for car insurance below.
Partner content: This content was created by a business partner of Dow Jones, independent of the MarketWatch newsroom. Links in this article may result in us earning a commission. Learn More
The cheapest full-coverage car insurance companies like USAA, Nationwide and Geico start at $119 per month on average.
Discover if you are overpaying for car insurance below.
Secure. Fast. Free.
We at the MarketWatch Guides team have compared the best car insurance companies to find the most affordable options for drivers. In this article, we’ll examine which companies offer the cheapest full-coverage car insurance and introduce our top picks.
Key Takeaways:
According to our rate estimates, Nationwide offers the cheapest full-coverage car insurance at an average rate of $119 per month for a single 35-year-old with a clean driving record and good credit. USAA is also another cheap option, at $126 per month. However, USAA is only available to members of the military, veterans and their children.
Below, you can see annual and monthly rate averages for a variety of major car insurance companies.
Car Insurance Company | Average Annual Rate | Average Monthly Rate |
Nationwide | $1,433 | $119 |
USAA | $1,512 | $126 |
Travelers | $1,595 | $133 |
Geico | $1,596 | $133 |
State Farm | $1,657 | $138 |
American Family Insurance | $1,851 | $154 |
Progressive | $2,030 | $169 |
Allstate | $2,598 | $216 |
Farmers | $3,169 | $264 |
Our rate data shows Nationwide has the least-expensive full-coverage car insurance rates overall. Good drivers can find rates around $1,433 per year or $119 per month from the company. These rates are about 29% cheaper than the industry average.
Next, we’ll look at the cheapest full-coverage car insurance companies broken down by state, driver age and driving record.
Your location is one of the biggest factors that can influence your car insurance premium. This section shows the cheapest provider based on our estimates for a 35-year-old driver in each state.
While companies like Geico and USAA offer cheap car insurance on average, the cheapest company in each state varies. Regional providers like Country Financial and Farm Bureau insurance tend to be affordable as well, so we encourage you to compare all your options.
State | Cheapest Car Insurance Company* | Average Annual Rate |
---|---|---|
Alabama | Travelers | $1,332 |
Alaska | Geico | $1,020 |
Arizona | Geico | $1,173 |
Arkansas | State Farm | $1,346 |
California | Mercury | $1,748 |
Colorado | Geico | $1,306 |
Connecticut | Geico | $995 |
Delaware | Travelers | $1,554 |
District of Columbia | Geico | $1,579 |
Florida | State Farm | $1,813 |
Georgia | Auto-Owners Insurance | $1,544 |
Hawaii | Geico | $1,162 |
Idaho | State Farm | $881 |
Illinois | Pekin | $792 |
Indiana | Geico | $1,176 |
Iowa | Pekin | $816 |
Kansas | Geico | $1,263 |
Kentucky | Geico | $1,583 |
Louisiana | Southern Farm Bureau | $1,926 |
Maine | Auto-Owners Insurance | $758 |
Maryland | Geico | $1,245 |
Massachusetts | Progressive | $1,776 |
Michigan | Progressive | $2,209 |
Minnesota | State Farm | $1,228 |
Mississippi | Progressive | $1,212 |
Missouri | Travelers | $1,477 |
Montana | Progressive | $972 |
Nebraska | Nationwide | $1,332 |
Nevada | State Farm | $1,376 |
New Hampshire | Auto-Owners Insurance | $833 |
New Jersey | Geico | $1,472 |
New Mexico | Central Mutual | $1,358 |
New York | Progressive | $1,302 |
North Carolina | Erie Insurance | $1,043 |
North Dakota | American Family Insurance | $1,401 |
Ohio | Nationwide | $825 |
Oklahoma | State Farm | $1,502 |
Oregon | State Farm | $1,210 |
Pennsylvania | Travelers | $907 |
Rhode Island | Travelers | $1,806 |
South Carolina | American National | $783 |
South Dakota | State Farm | $1,816 |
Tennessee | State Farm | $1,223 |
Texas | Texas Farm Bureau | $1,205 |
Utah | Geico | $1,129 |
Vermont | Union Mutual Fire Insurance | $708 |
Virginia | State Farm | $1,185 |
Washington | Geico | $1,304 |
West Virginia | State Farm | $1,378 |
Wisconsin | Geico | $1,059 |
Wyoming | American National | $918 |
*This table doesn’t include USAA. While it’s often the cheapest provider in many states, it’s only available to military members, veterans and their children.
Age is another important factor in how much you pay for full-coverage car insurance. Younger drivers are associated with higher rates of accidents and violations, so they pay more for car insurance. Our averages show Geico is often the cheapest provider for drivers of different ages.
Age | Cheapest Provider* | Average Annual Rate |
---|---|---|
16 | Erie Insurance | $4,259 |
17* | Geico | $3,646 |
18* | Geico | $3,161 |
19* | Geico | $2,485 |
21* | Geico | $1,844 |
25 | Nationwide | $1,663 |
35 | Nationwide | $1,433 |
45 | Nationwide | $1,342 |
55 | Nationwide | $1,229 |
65* | Geico | $1,227 |
75* | Geico | $1,457 |
*Costs taken from 2022 information
**Not including USAA
Your driving record has a big impact on the rates you pay. Depending on your state, you may pay elevated car insurance rates for three to five years after an accident or violation.
According to our rate averages, State Farm, Nationwide and Geico are often affordable for drivers with an accident or violation. However, that’s not always the case. Let’s take a look at rate averages for a variety of situations.
After a speeding ticket, the company with the cheapest coverage is Erie Insurance. Our averages here apply to speeding 16 to 20 MPH over the limit, and we found this type of speeding ticket raises rates an average of $500 per year.
Car Insurance Company | Monthly Cost Estimate | Annual Cost Estimate |
---|---|---|
Erie Insurance | $141 | $1,690 |
USAA | $152 | $1,828 |
State Farm | $156 | $1,872 |
Nationwide | $157 | $1,878 |
Geico | $178 | $2,137 |
Progressive | $212 | $2,541 |
Running a stop sign puts people in danger and definitely raises your insurance rates. Our estimates show drivers pay $550 more per year on average for having this type of violation. Nationwide is the cheapest mass-market provider on our list, with rate averages of $1,650 per year.
Car Insurance Company | Average Annual Rate |
---|---|
USAA | $1,405 |
Nationwide | $1,650 |
Geico | $1,739 |
State Farm | $1,749 |
Travelers | $2,032 |
American Family Insurance | $2,061 |
Progressive | $2,477 |
Allstate | $2,738 |
Farmers | $3,323 |
*Data taken from 2022 information.
Having a DUI on your record can make your insurance rates go sky high. Our estimates show drivers pay an average of about $1,423 more per year for having a DUI on their records. That’s about 71% higher than average rates for a driver with a clean record. If a DUI stays on your record for 3 years, that’s about $4,269 more in car insurance.
Our averages show State Farm is generally the most affordable provider to have with a DUI on your record. Erie, Progressive and USAA are also affordable.
Car Insurance Company | Monthly Cost Estimate | Annual Cost Estimate |
---|---|---|
State Farm | $183 | $2,194 |
Erie Insurance | $206 | $2,474 |
Progressive | $212 | $2,548 |
USAA | $227 | $2,721 |
Nationwide | $274 | $3,288 |
Geico | $303 | $3,641 |
Having an at-fault accident can raise your rates by about 45%, according to our averages. State Farm tends to be the cheapest national provider to have in this situation, as it offers average annual rates of $1,953.
Car Insurance Company | Monthly Cost Estimate | Annual Cost Estimate |
---|---|---|
State Farm | $163 | $1,953 |
Erie Insurance | $164 | $1,962 |
USAA | $182 | $2,187 |
Nationwide | $197 | $2,368 |
Geico | $224 | $2,694 |
Progressive | $254 | $3,052 |
An at-fault accident and a speeding ticket on the same driving record combine to raise car insurance rates even more. Our averages show drivers with these two marks on their records pay about 86% more for car insurance annually. In this case, State Farm is the cheapest mass-market provider, averaging $2,077 per year.
Car Insurance Company | Average Annual Rate |
---|---|
USAA | $1,903 |
State Farm | $2,077 |
American Family Insurance | $2,259 |
Nationwide | $2,366 |
Travelers | $2,612 |
Geico | $2,836 |
Progressive | $3,329 |
Allstate | $4,173 |
Farmers | $4,193 |
*Data taken from 2022 information.
With two at-fault accidents on your record, you become a more risky driver to insure. Our estimates show drivers with two accidents, on average, pay more than double what drivers with clean records pay, which costs them an average of $2,031 more per year. In this situation, it would likely be best to have State Farm, USAA, American Family or Nationwide, as they’re the four cheapest major providers for drivers with two accidents on their records.
Car Insurance Company | Average Annual Rate |
---|---|
State Farm | $2,084 |
USAA | $2,565 |
American Family Insurance | $2,408 |
Nationwide | $2,797 |
Travelers | $2,935 |
Geico | $3,509 |
Progressive | $3,977 |
Allstate | $4,724 |
Farmers | $5,243 |
If you’ve had three at-fault accidents, you may have a hard time finding affordable car insurance. State Farm is a large insurer that typically offers the cheapest rates for these drivers, averaging about $2,341 per year. On average, drivers with three at-fault accidents in their recent insurance history pay $3,706 more per year for car insurance than people with clean driving records.
Car Insurance Company | Average Annual Rate |
---|---|
State Farm | $2,341 |
American Family Insurance | $2,826 |
USAA | $3,465 |
Nationwide | $3,974 |
Travelers | $4,085 |
Geico | $5,043 |
Allstate | $6,395 |
Farmers | $7,392 |
Progressive | $7,643 |
*Data taken from 2022 information.
After we considered average cost estimates for a variety of types of drivers, our top picks for the cheapest full-coverage car insurance were Nationwide, State Farm, Geico, USAA and American Family.
Full-coverage car insurance typically includes liability insurance, comprehensive and collision coverage. When combined, these three coverage types compensate other drivers when you cause an accident and also protect your vehicle from accident and non-accident damage.
Liability car insurance covers medical bills and car damage for other people in accidents you cause. Almost every state requires minimum levels of liability coverage, as it’s the most important kind to have.
For example, Nevada requires $25,000 of bodily injury liability coverage per person, $50,000 of bodily injury liability coverage per accident and $20,000 of property damage liability coverage per accident. These coverage limits are written as 25/50/20, and they’re similar to many other state minimums.
You can also get higher limits, even up to $300,000 or more in bodily injury coverage per person depending on the insurer. Having full-coverage insurance doesn’t require you to have more than your state’s minimum level of liability coverage, but higher limits offer better protection.
Also called “other-than-collision” coverage, comprehensive coverage covers repairs if your car is damaged by anything other than a car-related accident. This includes things like damage from crashing into a wall or damage from a hailstorm. Comprehensive insurance also covers damage from:
Comprehensive coverage will also usually cover theft of the entire vehicle.
Collision insurance covers repair bills for your car when you cause an accident. This insurance covers up to the value of your car or pays a settlement value if your car is totaled. If you have a vintage or luxury car that appreciates in value, you can get classic car insurance that covers up to an agreed-upon value.
The following choices are optional and usually considered separate from full-coverage insurance:
Not everyone on the road has insurance. Underinsured and uninsured motorist coverage protects you if someone without enough insurance causes an accident. It comes in two types — bodily injury and property damage — and often mirrors the coverage levels you select for liability insurance.
Some states require this coverage, so it would be included in full-coverage auto insurance policies in those cases. Other states don’t require it, but it’s still a good idea to have it. Many people drive with minimum liability limits, which often aren’t enough if someone needs extensive medical care after an accident.
Medical coverage is another optional type of insurance some states require. It comes in two varieties: medical payments coverage (MedPay) and personal injury protection (PIP). Both can cover medical bills for you and your passengers after an accident no matter who caused it. But PIP insurance adds coverage for death benefits and lost wages.
Some states have a no-fault car insurance system, which means drivers use their own insurance to cover medical bills no matter who caused the accident. These states usually require drivers to have minimum PIP coverage to make the system work.
To get the cheapest full-coverage car insurance, shop around and consider changing your coverage amounts or deductible to lower your overall costs.
One of the simplest ways to find a cheaper rate is to compare auto insurance quotes from multiple providers. You can use online quote tools like the one on this page as well as insurance agents or brokers in your area. There are many affordable regional providers that offer coverage in only a few states, so explore all of your options.
To save money, you can decrease the limits on your liability coverage until you meet the state-required amount. You could save money with a liability-only policy if your car is worth $5,000 or less and you own it, so take that into consideration too.
Another way to save money is to increase your deductible, which applies to comprehensive and collision coverage. Raising your deductible will lower your monthly cost because you’re taking on more of the risk if you get into an accident. Be sure you can afford to cover your deductible, of course.
Credit scores affect insurance rates in many states, so having good credit can help you get the best rates in the future. But if your score takes a nosedive, you might see the cost of insurance begin to rise.
Full coverage might be unnecessary in some situations. If your car is worth the same or less than your annual premium, full coverage isn’t worth it. Similarly, if the vehicle is old, it’s not worth insuring it for repairs with full coverage.
Full-coverage car insurance can be affordable if you know where to look. Our picks for the cheapest full-coverage car insurance providers are Nationwide, State Farm, Geico, USAA and American Family Insurance. Compare car insurance quotes from providers to find the best option for you.
Below are some frequently asked questions about the cheapest full-coverage car insurance policies.
The cheapest type of car insurance is minimum liability coverage. This covers property damage and medical bills for other people when you cause an accident, and it’s required in almost every state.
According to our rate estimates, Geico is about 19% cheaper than Progressive for full-coverage auto insurance. However, each person’s rate depends on factors including their location and driving history. Compare both companies to see which is cheaper for you.
Full-coverage insurance is usually required if you have an auto loan or lease on a vehicle. This is because the lender has an interest in keeping the vehicle in good condition. You aren’t required to have full-coverage insurance if you own your car outright.
According to our insurance premium data, minimum-coverage insurance costs an average of $627 per year while full-coverage car insurance costs an average of $2,008 per year. That makes minimum coverage about 69% cheaper than full coverage on average.
Yes, on average car insurance increased from 2022 to 2023. However, most of the increase was in full-coverage insurance, which went up by about 16%. On average, minimum-coverage insurance stayed relatively flat in 2023.
Full-coverage insurance fixes your car if you cause an accident or encounter environmental damage. It can be high if your driving record is poor or you live in an area with lots of environmental damage claims.
Because consumers rely on us to provide objective and accurate information, we created a comprehensive rating system to formulate our rankings of the best car insurance companies. We collected data on dozens of auto insurance providers to grade the companies on a wide range of ranking factors. The end result was an overall rating for each provider, with the insurers that scored the most points topping the list.
Here are the factors our ratings take into account:
Our credentials:
If you have questions about this page, please reach out to our editors at editors@marketwatchguides.com.