Dear Amy: My brother-in-law of 20 years has always been rude, hateful, disrespectful and in a perpetual bad mood.
My sister always made excuses for his bad behavior and so my family “turned the other cheek” and treated him with love and kindness, anyway.
One day at a party I overheard my brother-in-law telling his friend how he never liked me or my family. He then proceeded to make fun of us.
A few days later I confronted him and my sister about it. My brother-in-law confessed to hating me and my family. He said we had done nothing bad to him personally – he just hated us.
My sister knew how he felt all along and now she’s acting like it’s not a big deal.
We don’t want anything to do with my brother-in-law ever again.
We are all feuding, and I don’t know what to do or how to save my relationship with my sister over this betrayal.
– Shocked
Dear Shocked: Your reaction to this insult seems to blame your sister – presumably for tolerating her husband’s long-standing hatred and disrespect of your family.
Your sister is not responsible for her husband’s atrocious behavior. But it seems as if he has pulled the pin on a grenade and tossed it into the middle of your family.
You might look on this weird episode of brutal honesty as a liberation of sorts. You are under no obligation to spend time with him, interact with him, or worry about his estimation of you. Declining to spend time with him will relieve him of any obligation or expectation to be in the presence of people he hates.
In this context, “turning the other cheek” might translate into accepting that your sister has chosen to be with him and seems to be staying with him.
Perhaps you could adopt a loving and understanding attitude toward her. Her situation does not sound easy.
Stories by Amy Dickinson
- Ask Amy: Friend worries as pal cuts corners on home repairs. ‘Should I say something?’
- Ask Amy: Being drunk doesn't excuse girlfriend's breach of confidence
- Ask Amy: Does ‘bro code’ really mean a friend shouldn’t date a friend’s ex?
- Ask Amy: Did I waste the best years of my life living with a cheating wife?
- Ask Amy: Shoddy CPA cost me a lot of money and happens to be my boyfriend’s dad
You can email Amy Dickinson at askamy@amydickinson.com or send a letter to Ask Amy, P.O. Box 194, Freeville, NY 13068.