Skip to content
NOWCAST Pittsburgh's Action News 4 at Noon
Watch on Demand
Advertisement

Suspect identified in homicide of 83-year-old man in Fayette County

State police said the man had been reported missing early Saturday.

Suspect identified in homicide of 83-year-old man in Fayette County

State police said the man had been reported missing early Saturday.

TO THE VICTIM. WHILE THE INVESTIGATION INTO THE SHOOTING DEATH OF ANTHONY DICENZO IS STILL TECHNICALLY OPEN, AUTHORITIES BELIEVE THEY HAVE THE GUY RESPONSIBLE IN CUSTODY, NORMAN PENNINGTON, AND THEY CLAIM HE DID IT OVER A PURPORTED REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT, MR. PENNINGTON ADMITTED THAT HE WAS ESSENTIALLY SWINDLING MR. DICENZO OUT OF THE MONEY, AND THAT MR. DICENZO WAS CONFRONTING HIM ABOUT THAT MONEY. THAT MONEY THAT FAYETTE COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY MIKE AUBLE IS TALKING ABOUT APPARENTLY AMOUNTED TO $30,000, ABEL SAID. TROOPERS DETERMINED AND DICENZO PAID. THE 65 YEAR OLD PENNINGTON THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS WITH THE INTENT OF INVESTING IN REAL ESTATE, BUT THAT PENNINGTON HAD NO INTENTION OF EVER GOING INTO BUSINESS WITH DICENZO. A COUPLE DAYS BEFORE DICENZO WAS LAST SEEN ALIVE, ABEL SAID DICENZO’S WIFE RECALLED HEARING HER HUSBAND ON THE PHONE WITH PENNINGTON, DEMANDING HE GET HIS MONEY BACK. FAST FORWARD TO APRIL 13TH. POLICE FIND DICENZO’S BODY IN HIS WHITE CADILLAC. IT WAS DETERMINED THAT MR. DICENZO SUFFERED TWO GUNSHOT WOUNDS TO THE HEAD. FURTHER THAT HE HAD LIKELY BEEN SHOT WHILE IN THE DRIVER’S SEAT, THEN MOVED TO THE REAR OF THE VEHICLE. TROOPERS DISCOVERED A DISNEY FROZEN BLANKET AND GARBAGE BAG COVERING THE DRIVER’S SEAT, AS WELL AS OTHER EVIDENCE THAT INDICATED MR. DICENZO HAD BEEN KILLED AT ANOTHER LOCATION. TROOPERS ALLEGE THAT CELL PHONE DATA INDICATED THAT OTHER LOCATION WAS PENNINGTON’S PROPERTY. EVENTUALLY, MR. PENNINGTON CONFESSED TO KILLING MR. DICENZO IN THE VEHICLE AS IT WAS PARKED IN HIS DRIVEWAY. THEN MOVING THE VEHICLE AND BODY TO RIFFLE HOLLOW ROAD. KEY TO THE INVESTIGATION WAS A WITNESS INTERVIEW WITH PENNINGTON, HIS WIFE, WHO ALLEGEDLY TOLD INVESTIGATORS THAT SHE SAW HER HUSBAND DRIVE DICENZO’S WHITE CADILLAC ON APRIL 12TH, THE DAY DICENZO DISAPPEARED. ULTIMATELY, THE INFORMATION THAT SHE HAS PROVIDED US IS IS VERY -- FOR HIM. PENNINGTON HAS AN EXTENSIVE CRIMINAL HISTORY, AND AS A FELON, HE WAS NOT ALLOWED TO HAVE A GUN, ABEL SAYS. HE DUMPED THE WEAPON USED IN THIS CRIME IN THE DUNLAP CREEK. RE
Advertisement
Suspect identified in homicide of 83-year-old man in Fayette County

State police said the man had been reported missing early Saturday.

The suspect accused of shooting and killing an 83-year-old man last week in German Township had been "swindling" the victim out of money, according to the Fayette County district attorney.District attorney Michael Aubele briefed reporters Wednesday afternoon at the PSP barracks in Uniontown, hours after he confirmed to Pittsburgh's Action News 4 that a man named Norman Pennington was arrested and charged with homicide in Anthony Dicenzo's death.Aubele said during the investigation, state police learned that Dicenzo had given Pennington $30,000 for a purported real estate investment."Mr. Pennington admitted that he was essentially swindling Mr. Dicenzo out of the money and that Mr. Dicenzo was confronting him about that money," Aubele said.Pennington had no intention of paying Dicenzo back or pursuing a joint business venture, according to Aubele.Dicenzo was last seen alive on Friday, April 12. Police said he left his home in Brownsville around 5 p.m. and did not return. His family reported him missing early Saturday morning. Troopers later found the man dead inside his car, a 2011 white Cadillac STS, on Riffle Hollow Road. An autopsy showed Dicenzo died of two gunshot wounds to the head, the county coroner said Monday.Aubele said Dicenzo owned several rental properties and is well known in the Brownsville community."He's a father, grandfather, great-grandfather, and we're going to do everything that we can to secure justice for the Dicenzo family," he said in an interview earlier this week.A criminal complaint alleged that evidence from Dicenzo's car indicated that "Dicenzo had been pulled from the front driver side seat to the back seat.""Troopers discovered a Disney “Frozen” blanket and garbage bag covering the driver’s seat," Aubele said, "as well as other evidence indicating Mr. Dicenzo had been killed at another location."Pennington's wife told investigators that she was aware her husband owned a Disney "Frozen" blanket at one point, according to the criminal complaint.Cell phone data obtained via search warrants traced Dicenzo's phone to Pennington's property on April 12, and later to Riffle Hollow Road."Eventually, Mr. Pennington confessed to killing Mr. Dicenzo in the vehicle as it was parked in his driveway, then moving the vehicle and body to Riffle Hollow Road," Aubele said.Pennington has a "significant" criminal history, Aubele said, and as a felon, he was not permitted to have a gun at the time of the alleged crime.Aubele said Pennington dumped the gun in Dunlap Creek.

The suspect accused of shooting and killing an 83-year-old man last week in German Township had been "swindling" the victim out of money, according to the Fayette County district attorney.

District attorney Michael Aubele briefed reporters Wednesday afternoon at the PSP barracks in Uniontown, hours after he confirmed to Pittsburgh's Action News 4 that a man named Norman Pennington was arrested and charged with homicide in Anthony Dicenzo's death.

Advertisement

Aubele said during the investigation, state police learned that Dicenzo had given Pennington $30,000 for a purported real estate investment.

"Mr. Pennington admitted that he was essentially swindling Mr. Dicenzo out of the money and that Mr. Dicenzo was confronting him about that money," Aubele said.

Pennington had no intention of paying Dicenzo back or pursuing a joint business venture, according to Aubele.

Dicenzo was last seen alive on Friday, April 12. Police said he left his home in Brownsville around 5 p.m. and did not return. His family reported him missing early Saturday morning.

Troopers later found the man dead inside his car, a 2011 white Cadillac STS, on Riffle Hollow Road. An autopsy showed Dicenzo died of two gunshot wounds to the head, the county coroner said Monday.

Aubele said Dicenzo owned several rental properties and is well known in the Brownsville community.

"He's a father, grandfather, great-grandfather, and we're going to do everything that we can to secure justice for the Dicenzo family," he said in an interview earlier this week.

A criminal complaint alleged that evidence from Dicenzo's car indicated that "Dicenzo had been pulled from the front driver side seat to the back seat."

"Troopers discovered a Disney “Frozen” blanket and garbage bag covering the driver’s seat," Aubele said, "as well as other evidence indicating Mr. Dicenzo had been killed at another location."

Pennington's wife told investigators that she was aware her husband owned a Disney "Frozen" blanket at one point, according to the criminal complaint.

Cell phone data obtained via search warrants traced Dicenzo's phone to Pennington's property on April 12, and later to Riffle Hollow Road.

"Eventually, Mr. Pennington confessed to killing Mr. Dicenzo in the vehicle as it was parked in his driveway, then moving the vehicle and body to Riffle Hollow Road," Aubele said.

Pennington has a "significant" criminal history, Aubele said, and as a felon, he was not permitted to have a gun at the time of the alleged crime.

Aubele said Pennington dumped the gun in Dunlap Creek.