China | Banyan

Lip service

China seems to be winning its arguments with the West over Tibet and human rights

HYPOCRISY does not make you wrong, but it hands your critics a convenient weapon. When David Cameron, Britain’s prime minister, visited Sri Lanka for the recent Commonwealth summit, he was right to insist loudly and publicly on the need for a proper investigation into the carnage at the end of its civil war in 2009. But this week, on his next trip to Asia, that robust riling of his hosts laid him open to charges of double standards, as he indulged in three days of conciliatory schmoozing in China.

Neither Sri Lanka’s nor China’s government would be surprised that the passion for truth and justice aired so volubly in Colombo was buried far deeper in Mr Cameron’s luggage in Beijing. Neither accepts that Western “meddling” in their internal affairs on issues such as human rights flows from a genuine belief in universal principles. Rather, they see it as a self-serving diplomatic optional extra, to be discarded as soon as it jeopardises other interests. And China, unlike Sri Lanka, is powerful enough to make Western leaders hold their tongues.

This article appeared in the China section of the print edition under the headline "Lip service"

The rise of BlackRock

From the December 7th 2013 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from China

How Chinese networks clean dirty money on a vast scale

These shadowy “banks” are becoming the financiers of choice for transnational criminal gangs

The dark side of growing old

A coming wave of Alzheimer’s and other forms of dementia will test China to its limits


Examining the fluff that frustrates northern China

An effort to improve the environment has had unintended consequences