Houston Chronicle LogoHearst Newspapers Logo

The outlook for Houston is up to us

Whether bright or dim, Houston is at a tipping point to decide its future

By Updated

To say that 2017 was year of extremes for Houston is a gross understatement. We experienced the highest of highs and the lowest of lows, from a World Series Championship to the worst flooding in generations. In the wake of such an extraordinary year, it seems apropos to ask: Based on everything we experienced in 2017, should we be optimistic or pessimistic about the future of our region?

I am concerned about the region's future because we face some daunting challenges. Houston's future will depend to a great degree on how we address them.

Our region has many advantages not shared by most large metropolitan areas. Our embrace of diversity, our entrepreneurial, risk-taking legacy, being the energy capital of the world, having the largest medical center in the world, enjoying one of the country's lowest costs of living, are among a few of many such advantages. And although many of these can be harnessed to address the challenges we face, they are not enough to guarantee our future.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

So, here's what keeps me up at night.

Flooding. Our region faces two distinct flooding risks: upland flooding from intense rain events like Harvey that overpower the drainage system, and the much more serious risk of a major hurricane pushing a massive storm surge onshore. Both are solvable, but the solutions will take money and political will. So far, we have demonstrated neither.

RELATED: Fight flooding now!

RELATED: A 2017 call to action on flooding in Houston

If we continue to drag our feet on flooding the best we can hope for is that we will endure localized flooding every few years. This serial flooding will be a drag on the economy, both in terms of the actual costs and because companies will shy away from investing here. This type of flooding is inconvenient, costly and stressful, but it is survivable in regional terms.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

The much more devastating case would be that a major hurricane makes landfall near Freeport and brings the dirty side of the storm up the west side of Galveston Bay. Among hurricane experts this is referred to as the Scenario 7 Storm. The damage and loss of life of a Scenario 7 storm would cause is unimaginable. It would make Harvey look like a picnic. It would be a disaster from which the region may never fully recover, much as Galveston never fully recovered from the 1900 storm. Every year we do not address this risk, we are playing Russian roulette with Houston's future.

RELATED: Let 2018 become the year voters demand action on flood control

ALSO: A top 10 list for local Hurricane Harvey recovery

Regional governance. The Houston region has one of the most fragmented, dysfunctional governance structures in the country. The Harris County Appraisal District lists just under a thousand governmental entities in Harris Country alone. With the surrounding counties the total is nearly 1,700.

Particularly problematic is that large swathes of Harris County lie outside any municipality. If the unincorporated areas were a separate city, it would be the second-largest city in Texas and the fifth-largest city in the United States. By 2020, the unincorporated areas could be home to more people than the city of Houston.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

This creates a variety of problems because county governments in Texas were not designed to exercise municipal functions. For example, they have no authority to pass ordinances or collect sales taxes. This void has been filled with a plethora of special districts. In many areas, Houston has done "special purpose annexations" to allow some of those districts to collect sales taxes, with a cut going to the city, of course.

The Texas Legislature passed a law in the last session that prohibits cities from annexing without the permission of the affected landowners. While that is beneficial to landowners, it largely freezes the current jurisdictional map in place. The cities, especially Houston, will exercise extraterritorial jurisdiction over large areas that they will never be able to annex. And the residents in those areas won't be able to incorporate their own municipalities.

This patchwork of hundreds of overlapping government agencies is inefficient, with staggering administrative costs. Rationalizing our regional governance structure should be a priority.

Houston finances. Houston avoided an immediate fiscal crisis with stopgap pension reforms, but it still suffers from an unsustainable, structural budgetary deficit. A recent report by an outside consultant pegs the city's cumulative deficit over the next 10 years at more than $2 billion. That is an optimistic prediction. And the outlook beyond 10 years gets worse as the bill for the back-end-loaded pension plan comes due. As has been demonstrated by the Detroit experience, unless Houston fixes its finances, its fiscal problems will be a drag on the entire region.

Reliance on a fossil fuel economy. Houston has been blessed to be the energy capital of the world, but the time will come when the world will be burning far fewer fossil fuels. Coal use will decline the most, followed by oil. Natural gas probably has a longer runway. I am not suggesting fossil fuels will ever go away completely, but even a modest decrease in oil as a transportation fuel will be felt in Houston. And there are a lot of smart people working to make that happen sooner rather than later.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

There have been some nascent efforts at diversifying our regional economy. And we have some obvious areas we could potentially exploit, such as the Texas Medical Center and the Johnson Space Center, but the efforts so far have been anemic.

And there are other issues with which our region needs to grapple, including public education, early childhood education, traffic, income inequality, low health insurance coverage rates, thousands of abandoned buildings, an inefficient and dilapidated wastewater treatment system fouling our bayous. These are issues that are not unique to Houston and ones with which most other urban areas struggle. That does not mean they are unimportant.

Our region has a rich legacy of meeting tough challenges and doing great things. But our past triumphs do not guarantee our future success. That success must be earned every day, by an objective, dispassionate assessment of our strengths and weakness, by building regional consensus, by maintaining long-term discipline and staying focused on critical issues, by winning back taxpayer's trust that their tax dollars will be honestly and efficiently spent, by breaking down fiefdoms in favor of more effective governance models. In short, by doing the hard things it will take to guarantee our region's future.

And these are not challenges on which we can continue to dither. Houston is at a tipping point.

Should we be optimistic or pessimistic about Houston's future? Ultimately that depends on us, and our resolve to face our challenges head-on.

Advertisement

Article continues below this ad

King is a former Houston Chronicle columnist now writing at billkingblog.com.

|Updated
Bill King